Black Friday10% off any legal service

Shareholders Agreement For Two Founders In NZ

byAlex Solo10 min read

Yes, if you're starting a company with one other founder in New Zealand, you should have a shareholders agreement before things get too far along.

The reason is simple: two-founder companies can be wonderfully efficient when you're aligned, but surprisingly fragile when you're not. If you each own 50%, neither of you can outvote the other. If one person stops contributing, wants out, or disagrees on a big decision, the company can get stuck.

A good shareholders agreement doesn't mean you don't trust each other. It means you're being clear while the relationship is strong, so your business has a fair way to make decisions, protect equity and keep moving.

Do Two Founders Need A Shareholders Agreement In New Zealand?

Yes, most two-founder companies should have a shareholders agreement because the Companies Act 1993 doesn't cover all the practical issues you'll face as co-founders.

When you incorporate a company through the Companies Office, your company gets its own legal identity, company number and NZBN. The Companies Act 1993 gives you default rules for directors, shares, records and shareholder decisions.

Those rules are useful, but they don't usually answer questions like:

  • What happens if you both disagree and neither person will compromise?
  • Does a founder keep all their shares if they leave after six months?
  • Can one founder start a competing business on the side?
  • Who owns IP created before the company was set up?
  • Can a founder transfer shares to a spouse, family trust or investor?
  • What happens if one founder stops working in the business?

A shareholders agreement is a private contract between the founders and, usually, the company. It can sit alongside your company constitution, or your company may not have a constitution at all. If you do have both, they need to work together.

For a two-founder startup, the agreement should be less about lengthy legal wording and more about the pressure points: decisions, deadlocks, contribution, vesting, exits and IP. That's where two-founder companies tend to run into trouble.

Is A 50/50 Shareholding A Good Idea?

It depends, because a 50/50 split can feel fair at the start but can create deadlock if you don't build in a clear decision-making process.

Many co-founders choose 50/50 because they're both bringing something valuable. One person may build the product while the other handles sales, operations or industry relationships. That can be a perfectly sensible split.

The risk is that ordinary shareholder resolutions usually need more than 50% approval. Special resolutions under the Companies Act 1993 usually need at least 75% approval. If you each hold 50%, you both effectively have a veto on many decisions.

That can be helpful for major decisions, but painful for day-to-day growth. You don't want every disagreement about pricing, hiring or product direction to become a company-level standstill.

Ways To Reduce 50/50 Deadlock Risk

Your shareholders agreement can keep the 50/50 ownership but add practical ways to break deadlocks, such as:

  • Reserved matters: list the big decisions that need both founders' approval, like issuing new shares, changing the business model, taking on major debt or approving a large annual budget.
  • Role-based authority: let each founder make decisions within their area, such as product, finance, marketing or operations, up to agreed limits.
  • Escalation steps: require a meeting, written proposal and good-faith negotiation before a disagreement becomes a formal deadlock.
  • Independent adviser input: let an agreed accountant, chairperson or industry adviser give a non-binding recommendation.
  • Buy-sell or exit mechanism: if the deadlock can't be resolved, set out a fair buy-sell or exit mechanism within the shareholders agreement, such as a process for one founder to buy out the other or for both to consider an exit path.

Be careful with aggressive buy-sell mechanisms. They can favour the founder with deeper pockets, which may not be fair or commercially sensible for an early-stage startup. Implementing an actual buy-out may also require separate legal, accounting and tax advice.

What Should A Two Founder Shareholders Agreement Cover?

A two-founder shareholders agreement should cover ownership, control, contributions, IP, exits and what happens if your working relationship changes.

For many startups, the most useful agreement is one that matches how the business will actually run. A generic template may give you standard clauses, but it may not deal properly with your specific founder roles, any founders term sheet, funding plans, IP history or deadlock risks. A legal professional should tailor the document before you rely on it.

A Practical Clause Outline

Here's a fill-in outline you can use to think through what your agreement needs to say:

  1. Parties And Company Details: name the company, each founder, shareholding percentages, company number and NZBN if available.
  2. Business Purpose: describe what the company does now and whether it can expand into related products or markets.
  3. Founder Roles: set out what each founder is responsible for, expected time commitment and whether they're paid.
  4. Decision-Making: list who can approve day-to-day decisions and which decisions need unanimous consent.
  5. Deadlock Process: set out meeting steps, escalation, adviser input and what happens if there's no agreement.
  6. Vesting: explain when founders earn their shares, what happens if someone leaves early and how unvested shares are dealt with.
  7. IP Ownership: assign or licence relevant IP to the company, including code, designs, branding, content, customer lists and inventions.
  8. Confidentiality: protect trade secrets, customer information, financial data and product plans.
  9. Restraints And Conflicts: deal with side projects, competing businesses and using company opportunities for personal gain.
  10. Share Transfers: set rules for selling, transferring or issuing shares, including pre-emptive rights for existing shareholders.
  11. Funding: explain whether founders must contribute cash, record shareholder loans, give guarantees or approve investor funding.
  12. Exit Events: cover founder offboarding, resignation, death, incapacity, serious misconduct and long-term failure to contribute.

You may also need separate documents, such as contractor agreements, employment agreements, IP assignment deeds, confidentiality agreements and a company constitution.

How Should Founder Vesting Work?

Founder vesting usually works by letting each founder earn their shares over time, so a person doesn't keep a large stake after leaving early without contributing.

This is one of the biggest differences between a basic shareholders agreement and a startup shareholders agreement. If you issue all shares upfront with no vesting, a founder who leaves after three months may still own 50% of the company. That can make fundraising, decision-making and morale much harder.

A common approach is time-based vesting. For example, founders may vest their shares over four years, with a one-year cliff. That means no shares vest until the founder has contributed for 12 months, then the remaining shares vest monthly or quarterly over the next three years.

Worked Example: Mia And Arjun

Say Mia and Arjun start a Wellington SaaS company. They each receive 500 shares, so they each hold 50% on paper.

Their agreement says each founder's shares vest over four years, with a one-year cliff. After 12 months, 25% of each founder's shares vest. After that, the rest vest monthly over 36 months.

If Arjun leaves after 18 months, he has vested 187.5 shares out of 500, usually rounded based on the agreement. The company or Mia may have a right to buy back or cancel the unvested shares, depending on how the agreement is drafted and what the Companies Act 1993 allows.

That outcome is much fairer than Arjun leaving with the full 500 shares after only 18 months, while Mia continues building the company.

Vesting needs careful drafting. In New Zealand, buy-backs, share cancellations and financial assistance can trigger Companies Act requirements, including solvency considerations and board resolutions. Don't treat vesting as just a spreadsheet formula.

What Happens If One Founder Stops Contributing?

Your agreement should say what happens if one founder stops contributing, because silence usually gives you fewer clean options.

Contribution problems don't always look dramatic. Sometimes one founder slowly becomes unavailable, takes another job, misses product deadlines or stops attending customer meetings. Without clear rules, the other founder may feel like they're carrying the business while the inactive founder keeps the same ownership and voting rights.

Your shareholders agreement can deal with this in a few practical ways:

  • Minimum contribution: set expected hours, deliverables or role responsibilities for each founder.
  • Review process: require a written notice and a meeting if one founder believes the other isn't meeting their role commitments.
  • Cure period: give the founder a set period, such as 20 business days, to get back on track or agree a new role.
  • Good leaver and bad leaver rules: distinguish between leaving for health reasons, redundancy of role, serious misconduct or simply walking away.
  • Unvested shares: explain whether unvested shares are bought back, cancelled or transferred.
  • Director changes: set out when a founder must resign as a director if they stop being involved.

If a founder is also working for the company, make sure the role is documented properly. They may be an employee, contractor, director, shareholder, or more than one of these at the same time.

The Employment Relations Act 2000 matters if the company engages a founder as an employee. If a founder invoices the company as a contractor, the written agreement and the real working arrangement both need to line up.

Founder share terms shouldn't be used as a shortcut around employment obligations, tax settings or minimum entitlements. If a founder is paid through wages, remember the Holidays Act 2003 may also affect leave and holiday pay.

How Do You Protect IP In A Two Founder Startup?

You protect IP by making sure the company owns or has proper rights to use the assets the business relies on.

This is especially important in two-founder startups because IP is often created before incorporation. One founder may have written early code, designed the brand, registered a domain name, built a prototype or developed customer materials before the company existed.

If that IP isn't transferred or licensed to the company, it may still belong to the individual founder or a previous business. That can create problems when you raise investment, bring on contractors, commercialise the product or register trade marks through IPONZ.

Your shareholders agreement can include IP promises, but you may also need separate IP assignment or licence documents. These can cover:

  • software code, databases and technical documentation
  • logos, brand names and design files
  • copyright in website copy, pitch decks and marketing materials
  • product designs, know-how and processes
  • domain names, social media handles and account access
  • inventions and improvements created after the company starts

You should also check who created each asset and when. If a contractor helped build your app or brand, check the contract and the type of IP involved. In New Zealand, some paid commissioned copyright works, such as computer programs and certain artistic works, may belong to the person who commissioned them unless agreed otherwise. However, a written IP assignment or licence is still important to cover pre-existing materials, improvements, trade marks, confidential information and anything created before the company existed. Paying an invoice isn't always enough to give the company every right it needs.

For trade marks, registration through IPONZ can give stronger brand protection in New Zealand. Before you invest heavily in a name, check whether it's available and whether the company, not an individual founder, should own the application.

How Much Does A Shareholders Agreement Cost?

The cost depends on how complex your founder relationship, company structure and funding plans are.

A simple two-founder agreement with equal shares, basic vesting and straightforward decision-making will usually be less involved than an agreement for a startup raising capital, issuing different share classes, planning future share issues or dealing with overseas founders.

The main things that drive cost are:

  • whether you already have a company constitution
  • whether you need founder vesting or share buy-back mechanics
  • how detailed your deadlock process needs to be
  • whether IP assignments are needed
  • whether founder employment or contractor documents are also required
  • whether you're planning to raise investment soon

You have a few options. A free template may help you think through the topics, but it can miss New Zealand-specific issues or create inconsistent terms. An online fixed-fee service can be a good fit if you want price certainty and a tailored document. A traditional firm billing by the hour may suit more complex transactions or heavily negotiated investor documents.

Before you choose an option, ask what is included. Ideally, you want more than a document. You want the key commercial decisions explained, the Companies Act 1993 issues checked, and the agreement tailored to how you and your co-founder will actually work together.

Key Takeaways

  • A shareholders agreement is especially useful for two-founder startups because 50/50 ownership can create deadlock.
  • Your agreement should cover decision-making, reserved matters, vesting, founder contributions, IP, confidentiality and exit rules.
  • Founder vesting helps avoid the unfair result of someone leaving early but keeping a large shareholding.
  • If a founder works in the business, document whether they're an employee, contractor, director or a mix of roles.
  • Make sure the company owns or can use the IP it needs, especially anything created before incorporation or by contractors.
  • Templates can be a starting point, but a two-founder agreement works best when it's tailored to your roles, risks and growth plans.

If you'd like help with your shareholders agreement, founder vesting terms, IP assignments and company setup documents, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Need legal help?

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.