Black Friday10% off any legal service

Restrictive Covenant Vs Non-Compete In NZ Contracts

byAlex Solo10 min read

You want to protect the business you've built. Maybe an employee knows your pricing, a contractor has access to your customer list, or a senior team member could walk straight into a competitor's business next month.

It's natural to reach for a non-compete clause. But in New Zealand, the narrower clause is often the stronger one.

A restrictive covenant is the wider family of contract promises that limit what someone can do during or after working with you. A non-compete is just one type, and it's usually the hardest to enforce because it stops someone from working in a market at all.

The good news is that you don't always need the broadest restraint. You usually need the clause that protects the specific risk: customers, staff, suppliers, confidential information, or your IP.

What Is The Difference Between A Restrictive Covenant And A Non-Compete?

A restrictive covenant is any contract clause that restricts someone's conduct, while a non-compete is a specific clause that stops them from working for, or starting, a competing business.

That means every non-compete is a restrictive covenant, but not every restrictive covenant is a non-compete.

Common restrictive covenants in New Zealand employment agreements, contractor agreements, shareholder agreements and confidentiality agreements include:

  • Non-compete clauses: stopping someone from working for, advising, owning or starting a competing business for a set period.
  • Non-solicitation clauses: stopping someone from approaching your customers, clients, suppliers or staff.
  • Non-dealing clauses: stopping someone from doing business with certain customers, even if the customer approaches them first.
  • Confidentiality clauses: stopping someone from using or disclosing confidential business information.
  • IP assignment clauses: making sure work product, inventions, branding or code created for your business belongs to your business.
  • Garden leave clauses: keeping an employee away from customers and systems during their notice period while they remain employed.

When people search for restraint of trade in NZ, they're usually talking about these kinds of post-employment or post-engagement limits. The key point is that New Zealand courts and the Employment Relations Authority start from the position that restraints of trade are against public policy unless they're reasonable and protect a legitimate business interest.

So, the better question isn't which clause sounds strongest. It's which clause drafting is narrow enough to match the harm you're genuinely trying to prevent.

Are Non-Compete Clauses Enforceable In New Zealand?

Yes, non-compete clauses can be enforceable in New Zealand, but only if they're reasonable and go no further than needed to protect a legitimate business interest.

A non-compete is a serious restriction. It can stop someone from earning a living in their usual field, so it gets close scrutiny. A non-compete agreement clause that says an employee can't work for any competitor anywhere in New Zealand for 12 months will usually be much harder to justify than a clause that protects specific customers for three months.

When deciding whether a restraint is reasonable, the Employment Relations Authority or Employment Court may look at factors such as:

  • the employee's role and seniority
  • how much access they had to customers, pricing, strategy or trade secrets
  • whether they received something meaningful in return for accepting the restraint
  • the length of the restraint
  • the geographic area covered
  • the type of work or business activity restricted
  • whether the clause protects a real business interest, not just competition itself

New Zealand's Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017 also gives the court power in some situations to modify an unreasonable restraint rather than simply throw it out. But you shouldn't rely on a court or authority to fix an overreaching clause later. That path is uncertain, expensive and distracting.

For most small businesses, a non-compete should be the last option, not the default. If your real worry is a staff member contacting your customers, a non-solicitation clause is usually cleaner. If your real worry is misuse of pricing, designs, recipes, source code or systems, confidentiality and IP clauses may do the job more directly.

When Should You Use A Non-Solicitation Clause Instead?

You should use a non-solicitation clause when your main risk is losing customers, staff or suppliers because someone with inside access actively approaches them after leaving.

A non-solicitation clause is usually narrower than a non-compete because it doesn't stop the person from working in the industry. It only stops them from targeting particular relationships connected to your business.

For example, say Talia runs a Wellington IT support business with 9 staff. Her senior technician manages 25 client accounts and knows each client's renewal dates, pricing and system setup. Talia could try to use a 12-month non-compete stopping the technician from working for any IT provider in Wellington.

But a more focused approach might be:

  • a 6-month customer non-solicit for clients the technician dealt with in the last 12 months
  • a 6-month staff non-solicit to protect the small team
  • ongoing confidentiality obligations for pricing, passwords, processes and technical records
  • clear return of property and deletion obligations when the role ends

That combination targets the real harm: the technician using Talia's customer relationships and confidential information to shift work away. It doesn't stop the technician from taking a general IT job elsewhere.

That narrower approach is often more practical and more likely to be seen as reasonable.

Customers, Staff And Suppliers Need Different Wording

Try not to bundle every relationship into one broad restraint. Customers, staff and suppliers are different risks.

  • Customer non-solicit: focus on customers the person had real dealings with, or about whom they had confidential information.
  • Staff non-solicit: focus on poaching or encouraging employees and contractors to leave, rather than banning all contact.
  • Supplier non-solicit: use this where your supplier relationships, buying terms or exclusive arrangements are commercially sensitive.

The tighter the link between the person, the relationship and the business risk, the better your clause will usually look.

How Long Should A Restraint Last?

A restraint should last only as long as you genuinely need to protect the business interest at risk.

There isn't a single lawful duration for a restrictive covenant employment agreement in New Zealand. Reasonableness depends on the role, industry and information involved. A senior executive with deep customer and strategy access may justify a longer restraint than a junior employee with limited client contact.

In practice, many businesses use cascading restraint periods so a decision-maker can consider a shorter period if a longer one is too broad. For example, a clause might step down through 12 months, 6 months and 3 months. Cascading clauses need careful drafting, because a messy cascade can make the whole clause harder to read and harder to rely on.

Think about these questions before choosing the period:

  • How long does it take for customer relationships to stabilise after someone leaves?
  • How often do your customers renew, reorder or tender for work?
  • How long will the information stay commercially sensitive?
  • How quickly can you introduce a new account manager or contact person?
  • Is the person's role senior enough to justify the restraint?

For example, if customers buy weekly, a 3-month non-solicit may be enough to protect the handover. If customers renew annual contracts and the person knows the renewal strategy, you may need a different approach. But you still need to explain why the period fits the risk.

Be careful with long, blanket restraints. A 12-month non-compete might sound comforting, but if you can't justify it with evidence, it may give you less protection than a well-drafted 3 or 6-month non-solicit.

Do Contractors Need Different Restraint Clauses?

Yes, contractor restraints need extra care because a broad non-compete can blur the line between a genuine contractor and an employee.

Contractors are often brought in because you need flexibility or specialist skills. If your agreement says they can't work for anyone else in the market, can't send a substitute, and must work like a staff member, the arrangement may start to look less like genuine contracting.

Recent employment law changes are also relevant. The Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026 introduced a contractor gateway test for assessing whether certain workers are contractors rather than employees. One key theme is whether the written agreement and the real working relationship support contractor status, including whether the worker can provide services to others.

That means a broad non-compete in a contractor agreement can create tension and may call for restraint of trade advice. You may be trying to protect your business, but you may also be adding terms that point away from independent contractor status.

For contractors, it often makes more sense to focus on:

  • confidentiality and data security
  • ownership of work product and IP
  • non-solicitation of your customers and staff
  • conflict of interest disclosure
  • limits on using your name, portfolio or customer information
  • return or deletion of business records at the end of the engagement

Say Mike runs a cleaning business in Hamilton and uses an independent contractor for overflow commercial jobs. A clause banning the contractor from cleaning for any other business in Hamilton for 12 months is likely to be a red flag. A better fit may be a clause stopping the contractor from soliciting Mike's named commercial clients for 6 months, plus confidentiality around pricing, site access codes and client instructions.

The label in the agreement matters, but the practical working arrangement matters too. If the contractor status is important to your business model, get the restraint wording tailored before you use it.

What Should Your Restraint Clause Actually Say?

Your restraint clause should clearly identify the protected interest, the restricted conduct, the people or area covered, the time period and any exceptions.

Templates often miss the details that make a restraint workable. They may also use overseas wording that doesn't sit neatly with New Zealand law or your actual business model. A lawyer should tailor the clause before you use it, especially for senior employees, contractors, founders or anyone with customer access.

Here's a practical outline you can use to brief your legal team. It's not a finished clause, but it shows the moving parts.

  1. Protected Interest: state what you're protecting, such as customer relationships, confidential information, staff stability, supplier terms or goodwill.
  2. Who Is Restricted: name the employee, contractor, founder or shareholder role covered by the restraint.
  3. Restricted Conduct: spell out whether the person can't solicit, deal with, employ, assist, compete, disclose or use information.
  4. Restricted People Or Businesses: define the customers, clients, suppliers, staff or competitors covered, ideally by reference to real dealings or access.
  5. Time Period: choose a period that fits the risk, and consider a carefully drafted cascade if appropriate.
  6. Geographic Area: include an area only if it genuinely matters to your business and make it no wider than needed.
  7. Confidential Information: define the sensitive information clearly, including pricing, customer lists, systems, strategy, software, designs or know-how.
  8. Exceptions: allow ordinary work that doesn't harm your protected interest, such as working in a different role or with unrelated customers.
  9. Return And Deletion: require return of devices, documents, login access, files and copies when the engagement ends.
  10. Acknowledgement Of Reasonableness: record why the person agrees the restraint is reasonable, without relying on that statement alone.

Also think about the other documents around the restraint. Your employment agreement, contractor agreement, non-disclosure agreement, shareholder agreement, option plan and internal policies should line up. If they contradict each other, you may struggle to work out which obligation applies when someone leaves.

How Do You Choose The Right Clause For Your Business?

You choose the right clause by matching the restraint to the specific risk, then making it as narrow as you reasonably can.

A helpful way to decide is to start with the thing you're most worried about losing or exposing.

  • If you're worried about customers being approached: use a customer non-solicitation clause.
  • If you're worried about customers following the person even without an approach: consider whether a narrower non-dealing clause is justified for key clients.
  • If you're worried about staff being poached: use a staff non-solicitation clause.
  • If you're worried about trade secrets, pricing, source code or strategy: strengthen confidentiality, data access, return of property and IP clauses.
  • If you're worried about direct competition in a very senior role: consider a limited non-compete, but only after testing whether narrower clauses would be enough.

You should also check how the restraint works day to day. A clause that sounds neat on paper can be hard to apply if no one tracks which customers the person dealt with, what information they accessed or when the restraint starts and ends.

Before you finalise the contract, run through this checklist:

  • Can you explain the exact business interest being protected?
  • Does the person actually have access to that interest?
  • Is the period tied to your sales cycle, renewal cycle or handover process?
  • Is the geographic area necessary, or would named customers be better?
  • Would a non-solicit or confidentiality clause protect you without a non-compete?
  • Does the clause fit with the person's role, pay, seniority and bargaining position?
  • Have you kept records of why the restraint is needed?

If you can't answer those questions, the clause is probably too broad or too vague. Tightening it now is usually easier than trying to defend it later.

Key Takeaways

  • A restrictive covenant is the broader category. A non-compete is only one type of restraint, and it's usually the hardest to enforce.
  • New Zealand restraint clauses need to be reasonable and linked to a legitimate business interest, not just a general desire to avoid competition.
  • Non-solicitation, confidentiality, IP and return of property clauses often protect your business more cleanly than a broad non-compete.
  • Contractor restraints need extra care, especially after the 2026 contractor gateway changes, because overly restrictive terms may undermine contractor status.
  • The best restraint clause is specific: it names the risk, the conduct, the people or area, the time period and the exceptions.
  • Templates can be a useful starting point, but restraint clauses work best when they're tailored to your role, industry and customer relationships.

If you'd like help with choosing the right restraint clauses, updating your employment agreements, contractor terms or confidentiality protections, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Drafted by Taylor, Sprintlaw's AI, and overseen by Alex Solo. How we write

Protect your brand

What intellectual property should you protect?

If a name, logo, design or other creative work matters to the business, check who owns it, what permissions you need and whether clearance or registration is appropriate.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Protect your brand

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Keep reading

Related Articles

New Zealand Non-compete Clause Examples: Duration, Key Terms & Enforceability

New Zealand Non-compete Clause Examples: Duration, Key Terms & Enforceability

Non-compete clauses can protect confidential information, customer relationships and business goodwill, but only if the wording is carefully limited. This

10 Jul 2026
Read more
Can I Make A Contractor Sign A Non-Compete?

Can I Make A Contractor Sign A Non-Compete?

You can ask a contractor to sign a non-compete, but that doesn't mean it will hold up. Here's how to protect clients, staff, IP and confidential information in NZ.

30 Oct 2026
Read more
Are Non-Solicitation Clauses Enforceable In NZ?

Are Non-Solicitation Clauses Enforceable In NZ?

Want to stop ex-employees, contractors or suppliers from taking clients or staff? Here's how non-solicitation clauses work in New Zealand and how to keep them reasonable.

21 Oct 2026
Read more
Restraint Of Trade In New Zealand: Enforceability And Exit Options

Restraint Of Trade In New Zealand: Enforceability And Exit Options

Note: This article provides general information for New Zealand businesses and isn’t legal advice. Restraint of trade enforceability is highly fact-specific, so it’s worth getting advice on your particular clause and situation....

15 Jan 2026
Read more
How To Navigate And Challenge A Non-Solicitation Clause In NZ

How To Navigate And Challenge A Non-Solicitation Clause In NZ

If you’re running a small business, your customer relationships and your team can be two of your biggest assets. So when a key employee leaves (or a contractor moves on), it’s normal...

29 Apr 2026
Read more
Can An Employer Reduce Hours In New Zealand?

Can An Employer Reduce Hours In New Zealand?

Work has slowed down and you're wondering if you can cut staff hours? Here's how reduced hours, roster changes and restructuring work in New Zealand.

19 Nov 2026
Read more
Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.