Black Friday10% off any legal service

Do I Need A Contractor Agreement After The Gateway Test?

byAlex Solo9 min read

Mike runs a Wellington marketing agency. He brings in a freelance designer for 20 hours a week, pays her on invoice, and calls her a contractor. But she works fixed days, uses Mike's laptop, needs approval for every task, and can't take on work for similar agencies.

After the contractor gateway test changes, Mike wonders whether the label on the agreement is enough. The honest answer is no. A written contractor agreement still matters, but it needs to match how the work actually operates.

If you're hiring contractors in New Zealand, the goal isn't to make your paperwork look clever. It's to set up the relationship so the contract, payment model and day-to-day working arrangements all point in the same direction.

Does The Gateway Test Mean You Still Need A Contractor Agreement?

Yes, you still need a contractor agreement because the gateway test starts with what you've agreed in writing, but it doesn't stop there.

Under the Employment Relations Act 2000, as amended by the Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026, the contractor gateway test is designed to give businesses more certainty when engaging independent contractors. Broadly, the gateway looks at whether the arrangement has key contractor features, including a written agreement that says the person is an independent contractor, the worker having a reasonable opportunity to seek independent advice before signing, genuine freedom to work for others, and practical freedom around accepting work, availability and substitution.

If the gateway is satisfied, the worker is treated as a contractor for employment status purposes. If it isn't satisfied, the usual employee or contractor assessment can still apply. That broader assessment looks at the real nature of the relationship, including control, integration into your business, who supplies tools, who carries financial risk and whether the person is really operating their own business.

So, a contractor agreement isn't just a formality. It helps you:

  • record the commercial deal clearly from the start
  • show the contractor isn't being engaged as an employee
  • set expectations around control, availability and substitution
  • record that the contractor had a reasonable chance to get independent advice
  • protect your intellectual property and confidential information
  • reduce the risk of unpaid invoices, unclear scope and messy exits

The key is making sure the agreement matches the way you actually work together.

What Should Your Contractor Agreement Say About Control?

Your contractor agreement should give you control over the outcome, not day-to-day control over how the contractor does the work.

Control is one of the biggest practical differences between an employee and an independent contractor in New Zealand. With an employee, you can usually direct when they work, where they work, how they perform tasks and what systems they use. With a contractor, you should be buying a result or service, not managing them like a staff member.

That doesn't mean you have no say. You can still set:

  • the project scope and deliverables
  • deadlines and milestones
  • quality standards and brand requirements
  • health and safety requirements under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015
  • security, privacy and confidentiality rules

What you want to avoid is wording that looks like employment control. For example, be careful with clauses that say the contractor must work 9am to 5pm, report to a manager for daily approval, follow all internal staff policies, or perform any other duties you assign.

A better approach is to describe the services and outputs clearly. For example, instead of saying the contractor must work every Tuesday and Thursday under the direction of the marketing manager, you might say the contractor will deliver four social media design sets per month by the agreed campaign deadlines.

Your actual behaviour matters too. If the contract says the contractor controls their own method, but your team supervises every hour of their work, that mismatch can weaken your position.

How Should Substitution, Hours And Availability Work?

Your agreement should avoid locking the contractor into employee-style availability unless there's a clear commercial reason and the rest of the arrangement still supports contractor status.

The gateway test puts extra attention on whether the contractor is genuinely free to decide whether to accept work, when to work, and whether they can use someone else to perform the services. This is where many contractor arrangements become risky in practice.

Substitution

A substitution clause says the contractor can arrange for another suitably skilled person, such as a subcontractor, to do the work. This can help show the contractor is running an independent business, not personally filling a role in your team.

That said, you can still protect your business. The agreement can say any substitute must:

  • have the right skills, qualifications or experience
  • follow your confidentiality and privacy requirements
  • meet health and safety standards
  • meet any legal requirements for the work

If you want the substitution clause to support the gateway test, any vetting or approval process should be limited to checking legal requirements, relevant qualifications, or a relevant criminal record where justified by the nature of the work. A broad approval right, even if you say approval won't be unreasonably withheld, may not be enough.

If the contractor is genuinely the only person who can do the work, don't add a substitution clause just for show. A clause you never intended to use may not help much.

Hours And Availability

Try to avoid promising or requiring set hours unless the project genuinely needs them. If you need meetings, site access or customer appointments, describe those specific commitments rather than treating the contractor like rostered staff.

For example, the contractor must attend a one-hour project meeting each Monday is usually easier to justify than the contractor must be available from 8.30am to 5pm, Monday to Friday.

You should also avoid penalising a contractor for turning down extra work. If refusing extra tasks leads to removal from all future opportunities, that can look less like an independent business relationship.

What Should Payment, Equipment And Business Independence Look Like?

Your payment and equipment terms should show the contractor is operating a business, not simply receiving wages under a different label.

Employees are usually paid for time worked, supplied with tools and integrated into payroll. Contractors often invoice for services, set their own pricing, carry some financial risk and use their own tools or systems.

Your agreement should cover how the contractor gets paid. Depending on the work, this might be:

  • a fixed fee for a project or milestone
  • an hourly or daily rate for specialist services
  • a retainer for a defined scope
  • separate fees for extra work approved in writing

Hourly rates aren't automatically a problem. Many genuine contractors charge by the hour. The risk grows when hourly pay is combined with fixed staff-like hours, close supervision, no ability to work for others and no real business independence.

Equipment is another useful signal. If the contractor supplies their own laptop, tools, software, insurance and vehicle, that supports independence. If you provide everything and the contractor works only inside your systems, the relationship may look more like employment.

Here's a simple example. A Christchurch IT consultant invoices $2,400 plus GST each month under an IT services agreement to monitor a client's systems. She uses her own laptop worth $1,800, pays for her own software licences, works for three other clients, and can send a qualified colleague if she's unavailable. That arrangement is much easier to support as contracting than a technician who works 40 hours each week on your roster, uses your equipment and needs your approval for every task.

If the contractor is GST-registered or has an NZBN, that can help show business independence, but it's not decisive on its own.

What If The Contract And Day-To-Day Practice Don't Match?

If the contract and the work practices don't match, the practical reality can become a major problem.

New Zealand employment status questions don't turn only on the words in the agreement. If the gateway test isn't met, the real nature of the relationship may be examined. That means your emails, rosters, payment records, onboarding process and management style can all matter.

Misclassification can be expensive because the person may be found to have employee rights. Depending on the situation, that can raise issues such as:

  • minimum employment standards under the Employment Relations Act 2000
  • holiday and leave entitlements under the Holidays Act 2003
  • minimum wage obligations under the Minimum Wage Act 1983
  • PAYE, KiwiSaver and payroll record issues, which you should check with your accountant or tax adviser
  • health and safety duties, which can apply to contractors as well as employees

The best time to fix a mismatch is before it becomes a problem. Review both the paperwork and the working relationship. Ask yourself:

  • Do we tell the contractor exactly how to do the work, or just what result we need?
  • Can the contractor work for others, including businesses in a similar industry?
  • Can the contractor say no to extra work without being punished?
  • Do we require set hours when the project doesn't really need them?
  • Does the contractor use their own equipment and systems where practical?
  • Are we onboarding them like staff, with an employee handbook and internal role title?

If the honest answer points towards employment, you may need an employment agreement instead. That's not a failure. It's better to use the right structure from day one than try to force a contractor model that doesn't fit.

Contractor Agreement Outline To Update Before You Hire

A contractor agreement should be tailored to your business, the work and the level of risk. Free templates can be a helpful prompt, but they often miss the parts that matter most for your industry and working model.

Use this as a fill-in outline, not a finished legal document. Your lawyer or legal adviser should review the contractor agreement before you use it.

  1. Parties And Background: Name your business, the contractor and the purpose of the engagement.
  2. Contractor Status: State that the contractor is an independent contractor, not an employee, partner or agent.
  3. Independent Advice: Give the contractor a reasonable opportunity to seek independent advice before they sign, and keep a record of that opportunity.
  4. Services And Deliverables: Describe exactly what the contractor will provide and what is outside scope.
  5. Control And Method: Say the contractor controls how the services are performed, subject to agreed standards and lawful business requirements.
  6. Timing And Milestones: List deadlines, meetings and access times without creating unnecessary employee-style hours.
  7. Substitution: Set out whether the contractor can use a suitably qualified substitute. If approval or vetting is needed, limit it to legal requirements, relevant qualifications, or a relevant criminal record where justified by the nature of the work.
  8. Fees And Invoicing: Explain rates, fixed fees, GST treatment if relevant, invoice timing and payment terms.
  9. Equipment And Expenses: Say who provides tools, software, vehicles, insurance and reimbursable expenses.
  10. Freedom To Work For Others: Confirm the contractor can work for other clients, with sensible limits for confidentiality and conflicts.
  11. Intellectual Property: Make clear who owns the work product and when ownership transfers to your business.
  12. Confidentiality And Privacy: Protect business information, customer data and obligations under the Privacy Act 2020.
  13. Health And Safety: Set practical site, systems and reporting requirements where relevant.
  14. Termination: Include how either side can end the engagement and what happens to unfinished work, final invoices and business property.
  15. Records: Require invoices, approvals, variation records and evidence of completed milestones to be kept.

Once you've updated the agreement, update your onboarding too. Send the draft before work starts, give the contractor reasonable time to review it, tell them they can seek independent advice, and avoid treating the process like staff induction unless the same step is genuinely needed for site access, safety, privacy or security.

The document should be a reflection of the relationship, not a separate story sitting in a folder.

Key Takeaways

  • The gateway test doesn't remove the need for a written contractor agreement. It makes the agreement and work practices even more connected.
  • The worker must have a reasonable opportunity to seek independent advice before signing if you're relying on the gateway test.
  • Your contract should focus on outcomes, deliverables and standards, not employee-style control over every hour and task.
  • Substitution, freedom to work for others and freedom to turn down extra work can all help support contractor status, but substitution approval should be tightly limited.
  • Payment, equipment, invoicing, GST registration and an NZBN can support business independence, but none of them fixes a staff-like arrangement on its own.
  • A tailored contractor agreement works best when it's paired with practical onboarding and management habits that fit a genuine contractor relationship.

If you'd like help with your contractor agreements, gateway test settings, IP and confidentiality clauses, or employment status risk, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Drafted by Taylor, Sprintlaw's AI, and overseen by Alex Solo. How we write

Get employment right

When should you get employment help?

Employment topics can become risky quickly when documentation, consultation, termination or contractor status is involved.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Get employment right

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Keep reading

Related Articles

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.