Black Friday10% off any legal service

Can You Restrain A Contractor From Taking Clients?

byAlex Solo10 min read

Mei runs a Wellington social media agency. She brings in a contractor to help manage a busy client's campaigns, gives them access to the client's strategy, pricing and contact details, and introduces them as part of the delivery team.

Three months later, the contractor finishes the job. Soon after, Mei finds out they've contacted the client directly and offered to do the same work for less.

If that sounds familiar, you're not overreacting. Client relationships are often one of the most valuable parts of your business. The tricky part is protecting them without using a restraint clause that's so broad it won't stand up.

Here's how contractor non-solicitation clauses usually work in New Zealand, and how to make them practical, targeted and fair.

Can You Stop A Contractor From Taking Your Clients?

Yes, you can try to stop a contractor from taking your clients, but only if your restraint is reasonable and protects a legitimate business interest.

In New Zealand, restraint of trade clauses are treated carefully because they limit someone's ability to work. A court won't usually enforce a restraint just because you'd prefer not to have competition. You need to point to something your business is genuinely entitled to protect.

For client poaching, the stronger interests usually include:

  • Client relationships that your business built and paid to develop.
  • Confidential information, such as pricing, margins, client contacts, proposals, workflows or strategy.
  • Goodwill attached to your brand, reputation and customer base.
  • Investment in training or introductions, where you brought the contractor into a client relationship they didn't previously have.

A clause that says a contractor can't work in the same industry anywhere in New Zealand for two years is likely to be hard to justify. A clause that says they can't approach the specific clients they worked with for six months after the contract ends is much more targeted.

That difference matters. The goal isn't to punish the contractor for leaving. It's to stop them using the access you gave them to divert your clients straight away.

What Makes A Contractor Restraint Clause Enforceable In NZ?

A contractor restraint clause is more likely to be enforceable if it's no wider than reasonably necessary to protect your business.

New Zealand courts look closely at the wording and the surrounding facts. The label you use, such as restraint, non-solicitation or client protection, won't save a clause that's too broad in practice.

When you're drafting or reviewing a restraint clause, focus on these points:

  • The protected clients: Is the clause limited to clients the contractor actually dealt with, learned confidential information about, or was introduced to through your business?
  • The restricted conduct: Does it stop active poaching, or does it try to stop all work for anyone who has ever been connected to your business?
  • The timeframe: Is the period realistic for your industry and client cycle?
  • The geography: Do you really need a territory, or is a client-based restriction enough?
  • The contractor's role: Did they have real client influence, or were they doing back-end work with no client contact?
  • The bargaining position: Was the agreement negotiated fairly, or was it imposed on a small contractor with no real chance to discuss it?

There isn't a fixed statutory maximum period for restraints in New Zealand. A three-month period might be too long in one situation, while a 12-month period might be reasonable in another. It depends on the relationship, the type of clients, the information involved and how long your client connection needs protection.

If a restraint is over the top, the practical risk is simple: you may spend time and money relying on a clause that doesn't give you the protection you thought you had.

Is A Non-Solicitation Clause Better Than A Non-Compete?

Often, yes. A non-solicitation clause is usually easier to justify than a broad non-compete because it targets client poaching rather than stopping the contractor from working altogether.

A non-compete might say the contractor can't provide similar services to anyone in a particular area or industry for a period of time. That's a serious limit on their ability to earn income, so it can be difficult to enforce unless you have a very strong reason.

A non-solicitation clause is narrower. It usually says the contractor can't actively approach, entice or encourage certain clients to move their work away from you.

For many small businesses, the better approach is a layered set of protections:

  • Non-solicitation: The contractor can't approach your clients for competing work.
  • Non-dealing: The contractor can't accept work from protected clients, even if the client approaches them first. This is stronger and needs careful wording.
  • Confidentiality: The contractor can't use or disclose your confidential information outside the engagement.
  • Return of materials: The contractor must return or delete client files, data and business materials when the contract ends.
  • IP ownership: Your business owns or can use the work product created for you, depending on what you've agreed.

Be careful with non-dealing or non-compete wording. Unlike a solicitation-only restraint, a clause that stops a contractor accepting work from certain clients may restrict the contractor from performing work for another person, which can affect whether the arrangement satisfies the contractor gateway test. Get the clause tailored so it protects client relationships without unnecessarily undermining contractor status.

Say you run an IT support business and you engage a contractor to cover overflow tickets for three named clients. A clause that stops the contractor from soliciting those three clients for six months is likely to look more reasonable than a clause stopping them from doing any IT support work in Auckland for a year.

The more precisely the clause matches the risk, the stronger your position usually is.

How Does The Contractor Gateway Test Affect Restraints?

The contractor gateway test matters because heavy restrictions on a contractor can make the relationship look more like employment than genuine contracting.

The Employment Relations Act 2000 was amended by the Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026. Since 21 February 2026, a contractor gateway test has applied when working out whether a worker is a specified contractor.

One key part of the gateway is whether there's a written agreement that describes the person as an independent contractor. Other parts look at the practical freedom the person has, including whether they can work for others and how much control you have over their availability and tasks.

This is where restraint clauses need care.

If your contractor agreement says the contractor is independent, but also says they can't work for any other business, can't work with competitors, must be available whenever you ask and can be penalised for saying no to extra work, you may create employment status risk.

A targeted client non-solicitation clause is different from an exclusivity clause. You're not saying the contractor can't run their own business or work for others. You're saying they can't use your client access to poach your clients.

To reduce risk, your contractor agreement should line up with how the arrangement works in real life. For example:

  • avoid unnecessary exclusivity unless there's a strong commercial reason;
  • make it clear the contractor can work for others, subject to confidentiality and conflict obligations;
  • limit client restraints to clients or opportunities connected with your business;
  • avoid controlling day-to-day work like you would with an employee;
  • use a written contractor agreement before work starts, not after the relationship breaks down.

If your contractor works mainly for you, follows your roster, uses your systems, has little freedom to refuse work and is heavily restrained, get tailored employee or contractor advice. The label in the contract won't be enough on its own.

How Long Can A Contractor Non-Solicitation Clause Last?

It depends, but shorter and more targeted periods are usually easier to defend than long, blanket restrictions.

There's no single safe number under New Zealand law. The right period depends on how your business wins and keeps clients.

Think about questions like:

  • How often do clients renew or rebook your services?
  • How long does it take you to introduce a replacement contact after the contractor leaves?
  • How sensitive is the information the contractor accessed?
  • How long do pricing, strategy or proposal details stay commercially useful?
  • Did the contractor have direct influence over the client relationship?

Here's a worked example.

Mei's social media agency has a $4,000 per month client on a six-month campaign. The contractor helped with reporting, attended fortnightly client calls and saw Mei's campaign strategy and pricing. A six-month non-solicitation clause for clients the contractor worked with during the last 12 months of the engagement may be easier to justify because it gives Mei time to stabilise the relationship and renew the campaign cycle.

But if the contractor only designed one graphic, never spoke to the client and didn't access strategy or pricing, the same six-month restriction may be harder to justify. A confidentiality clause and clear IP terms may do most of the work instead.

Be careful with rolling or cascading periods that try every possible combination, such as 24 months, 18 months, 12 months, six months and three months across very wide client groups. They can help in some contracts, but they also make the clause harder for a contractor to understand. Clear drafting is usually better than trying to cover everything.

What Should Your Contractor Client Poaching Clause Say?

Your clause should clearly identify who is protected, what the contractor can't do, how long the restriction lasts and what exceptions apply.

Templates often miss the commercial detail that makes a restraint reasonable. Before you use any outline, a lawyer should tailor it to your contractor arrangement, industry and client risks.

A Practical Clause Outline

This isn't a finished legal clause, but it shows the key sections to think through.

  1. Parties And Engagement: Identify your business, the contractor and the services they will provide.
  2. Protected Clients: Define the clients covered, such as clients the contractor dealt with, was introduced to, or received confidential information about during a defined look-back period.
  3. Restricted Conduct: State whether the contractor can't solicit, canvass, approach, entice away or accept work from protected clients.
  4. Restricted Services: Link the restriction to services that compete with, replace or are similar to the services your business provides.
  5. Time Period: Choose a period that matches your client cycle and the risk, rather than defaulting to the longest period possible.
  6. Geographic Scope: Include a location only if it genuinely matters. A client-based restriction may be enough for online or service businesses.
  7. Confidential Information: Stop the contractor from using your client lists, pricing, proposals, systems or strategy for their own benefit.
  8. Return And Deletion: Require the contractor to return or delete client data, documents, logins and materials when the engagement ends.
  9. Conflicts And Disclosure: Require the contractor to tell you about conflicts that could affect your clients or confidential information.
  10. Reasonableness: Record why the restraint is needed, such as client access, confidential information and goodwill.

Also check how the clause interacts with privacy obligations and your client privacy policy. Client contact details can be personal information under the Privacy Act 2020. Your contractor agreement should say how that information can be used, stored, returned and deleted.

If the contractor communicates with clients, make sure they don't mislead clients about their role or your business. Misleading conduct can create risk under the Fair Trading Act 1986, especially if clients are told something false about who provides the service or whether your business is still involved.

What Else Can Protect Client Relationships?

A restraint helps, but it shouldn't be your only protection. Strong systems and clear documents often prevent the problem before it starts.

Consider these practical steps before you give a contractor client access:

  • Use a written contractor agreement from day one: Include confidentiality, IP, privacy, client contact rules and restraint wording before any client introductions happen.
  • Limit access to what the contractor needs: Don't give full client lists, pricing models or strategy documents if the contractor only needs part of the information.
  • Keep client ownership clear: Make sure clients know the contractor is helping your business, not replacing it as the direct provider.
  • Use business email accounts where practical: This helps keep client records with your business when the contractor finishes.
  • Control systems and logins: Remove access promptly at the end of the engagement.
  • Document client introductions: Keep records of when and why you introduced the contractor to each client.
  • Have an offboarding checklist: Confirm return or deletion of files, devices, client data and confidential information.

For example, if a contractor is helping with bookkeeping for five of your clients, you might give them access only to those client files, require them to use your project management system, and record that those five clients are protected clients under the agreement. If the contractor later approaches one of those clients, your records will make it much clearer what happened and why the restriction exists.

Good contract drafting and good operations work together. A beautifully worded clause won't help much if you've treated the contractor like the client's main supplier and left them with your whole customer database.

Key Takeaways

  • You can use a contractor non-solicitation clause in New Zealand, but it needs to be reasonable and tied to a legitimate business interest.
  • Targeted client restraints are usually stronger than broad non-competes that stop a contractor working in their trade.
  • The contractor gateway test has applied since 21 February 2026, so your contract and real working arrangement need to support genuine contractor status.
  • Non-dealing and non-compete wording can create extra contractor status risk if it stops the contractor performing work for others.
  • There's no fixed maximum restraint period, so choose a timeframe that matches your client cycle and the information being protected.
  • Confidentiality, privacy controls, IP terms and offboarding processes are just as important as the restraint clause itself.

If you'd like help with contractor agreements, non-solicitation clauses, confidentiality terms or contractor status settings, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Lock in the contract

Turning the information into a usable contract

Once money, deliverables or customer obligations are involved, the next step is usually a clear contract that matches how the business actually works.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Lock in the contract

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.