Black Friday10% off any legal service

Can You Stop An Ex Employee Taking Clients?

byAlex Solo10 min read

Can you stop an ex employee taking clients in New Zealand? Often, yes, but it depends on your contract, the type of client contact, and whether your restraint goes further than needed to protect your business.

It can feel pretty personal when someone you trained and trusted leaves, then starts approaching your clients. The good news is that you may have practical options, especially if your employment agreement includes clear non solicitation, confidentiality and intellectual property clauses.

The key is to move carefully. If you overreach, you can turn a protectable business issue into an employment problem. If you act too slowly, you may lose evidence and make it harder to protect the client relationships you have built.

Can You Stop An Ex Employee Taking Clients?

Yes, you may be able to stop an ex employee taking clients if you have an enforceable restraint or confidentiality obligation that covers what they're doing.

In New Zealand, you can't usually stop someone from earning a living just because they used to work for you. A restraint of trade clause needs to protect a real business interest, such as:

  • Client relationships the employee built or managed while working for you
  • Confidential information such as pricing, margins, proposals, client lists, strategy or technical processes
  • Goodwill connected to your brand, reputation and repeat customer base
  • Staff stability if the ex employee is trying to take key team members with them

A clause that says the employee can't work in your industry anywhere in New Zealand for two years is likely to be hard to justify for many roles. A clause that says they can't solicit clients they personally dealt with in the last 12 months for a period of 3 to 6 months may be more realistic, depending on the business.

Say Mike runs a commercial cleaning business in Auckland. His account manager, Jess, handled 25 ongoing office cleaning clients. Jess leaves and joins a competitor, then emails those same 25 clients offering a 10% cheaper rate using pricing she knew from Mike's business. If Jess's employment agreement has a tailored 6 month non solicitation clause and confidentiality clause, Mike may have a much stronger position than if the agreement only says staff must be loyal.

If you don't have a written restraint, you may still be able to rely on confidentiality obligations. But stopping client contact becomes harder if the ex employee is simply using general industry knowledge, public information or relationships they had before joining your business.

When Is A Restraint Of Trade Enforceable In New Zealand?

A restraint of trade is enforceable only if it's reasonable between you and the employee, and reasonable in the public interest.

New Zealand courts and the Employment Relations Authority generally start from the position that restraints limit a person's freedom to work. So, the clause needs to be carefully limited. The more senior and client facing the employee was, the easier it may be to justify a restraint.

Factors that usually matter include:

  • The employee's role: a senior salesperson with deep client relationships is different from a junior admin employee with limited client contact.
  • The type of restraint: a non solicitation clause is usually easier to justify than a full non-compete.
  • The time period: 3 to 6 months is often more defensible than 12 or 24 months, but the right period depends on your sales cycle and client relationship.
  • The geographic scope: a nationwide restraint may be excessive if your customers are local.
  • The clients covered: a clause covering clients the employee actually dealt with is usually stronger than a clause covering every lead your business has ever had.
  • Consideration: if you introduce a new restraint after employment has already started, you may need to provide something extra in exchange, not just ask the employee to sign.

The Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017 allows courts to deal with illegal or unreasonable contractual terms, and employment restraints are often assessed in the employment law context as well. In practice, this means a clause that's too broad may not work the way you hoped.

Some contracts include a cascading restraint, where the clause offers several options for time, area and client scope. These can help, but they need careful drafting. A messy cascading clause can create uncertainty rather than protection.

Is A Non Solicitation Clause Better Than A Non Compete?

Yes, in many small business situations, a non solicitation clause is more practical and more likely to be enforceable than a non compete.

A non compete tries to stop an ex employee working for a competitor or starting a competing business. That's a big restriction, so it needs strong justification. A non solicitation clause is narrower. It usually stops the ex employee from approaching, canvassing or enticing away certain clients, suppliers or staff.

For client poaching, a well drafted non solicitation clause should answer these questions clearly:

  • Which clients are protected?
  • Does it cover current clients, recent clients, prospective clients or all of them?
  • Does it apply only to clients the employee had dealings with?
  • How long does the restriction last?
  • What counts as solicitation?
  • Does it cover direct and indirect contact, such as using a new employer to approach the client?

The word solicit matters. If a client independently finds your ex employee online and asks for a quote, that may be different from the ex employee sending targeted messages to your client list. Your contract can deal with this by also covering acceptance of work from certain clients, but that's a stronger restriction and needs to be justified.

Example: A Clause That Is Too Wide

A clause saying, You must not provide services to any customer of the company for 24 months after leaving, anywhere in New Zealand, may be difficult to enforce for a mid level employee.

Example: A More Targeted Clause

A clause saying, For 6 months after employment ends, you must not solicit clients you had material dealings with in the 12 months before your employment ended, is usually more focused on protecting actual goodwill.

The best clause for your business depends on your role structure, sales process and client cycle. Templates often miss these details, which is why restraints work best when they're tailored before anyone signs.

What If The Ex Employee Is Using Confidential Information?

If an ex employee is using your confidential information, you may have stronger options even if your restraint clause is weak or missing.

Employees owe duties during employment, including duties of good faith under the Employment Relations Act 2000. After employment ends, the strongest ongoing duties are usually the ones written into the employment agreement, especially confidentiality, intellectual property and privacy obligations.

Confidential information can include:

  • Client lists that aren't public
  • Client preferences, renewal dates and decision maker details
  • Pricing models, discounts, margins and proposal templates
  • Supplier terms and operational processes
  • Marketing plans, product roadmaps and business strategy
  • Software code, designs, manuals, training material and internal documents

Not everything the employee learned at work is confidential. General skill, experience and industry knowledge usually belongs to the employee. For example, a hairdresser who remembers how to cut hair can't be stopped from using that skill. But if they copy your client database and text every client with a launch discount, that's a very different situation.

You also need to think about privacy. If your client database includes personal information, the Privacy Act 2020 may apply. That means you should only collect, use and disclose personal information for proper business purposes, keep it secure, and be careful about who can access it. If an ex employee has taken personal information, you may need to assess whether there has been a privacy breach, update your employee privacy processes and decide whether any notification steps are needed.

When confidential information is involved, act quickly but calmly. Disable system access, preserve logs and avoid making accusations you can't yet support. If you monitor email, devices or accounts, stick to your policies and keep the review targeted to business systems and business information.

What Should You Do First If You Suspect Client Poaching?

You should first preserve evidence, check the contract and stop further access to business systems before sending any strong messages.

It's tempting to call the ex employee or the client straight away. Sometimes that helps. But if you move too fast, you may tip them off, lose records or say something that makes the situation harder to resolve.

A Practical First Response Checklist

  1. Secure your systems: remove access to email, CRM, shared drives, messaging tools, passwords and client portals.
  2. Preserve records: keep copies of employment agreements, policies, exit documents, emails, CRM logs, download logs and client communications.
  3. Identify the clients affected: list which clients have been contacted, when, by whom and what was said.
  4. Check the clauses: look for restraint of trade, non solicitation, confidentiality, intellectual property and return of property clauses.
  5. Speak to client facing staff: ask for facts, not rumours. Record dates, names and exact words where possible.
  6. Keep client messaging professional: reassure clients about continuity and service without attacking the ex employee.
  7. Get tailored advice early: especially before threatening legal action, contacting the new employer or alleging misconduct.

A calm first letter can be useful. It might remind the ex employee of their obligations, ask them to preserve and return confidential information, and request written confirmation that they haven't solicited restricted clients. Keep it factual and attach the relevant contract clauses.

If you write to the new employer, be extra careful. You can put them on notice of the contractual obligations if you have a reasonable basis for doing so, but don't overstate the position or make claims you can't prove.

If the situation has already become a live dispute, you may need help from a New Zealand employment or disputes practitioner. Getting your contracts and internal processes right can also reduce the chance of ending up there next time.

What Should Your Employment Contract Include?

Your employment contract should include clear, role specific clauses that protect client relationships, confidential information and business materials without going further than necessary.

For employees, New Zealand law requires a written employment agreement. The agreement should reflect the Employment Relations Act 2000 and other workplace laws, including the Holidays Act 2003 where leave and holiday pay are dealt with. For restraints, the wording needs to be especially careful because broad boilerplate clauses often fail when you need them most.

Fill In Outline For A Client Protection Clause Pack

This is an outline only, not a finished document. A lawyer should tailor it before you use it with staff.

  1. Role And Client Exposure: describe whether the employee will manage clients, pricing, proposals or sales relationships.
  2. Confidential Information: define the information you protect, such as client lists, pricing, margins, systems and strategy.
  3. Return And Deletion: require the employee to return devices, documents and data, and delete copies when employment ends.
  4. Non Solicitation Of Clients: state which clients are covered, what contact is restricted and how long the restriction lasts.
  5. Non Interference With Staff And Suppliers: stop targeted approaches to key staff or suppliers where you have a real business reason.
  6. Intellectual Property: confirm that work created in the role belongs to your business, where appropriate.
  7. System Access And Monitoring: explain business system use, access controls and monitoring in a way that aligns with privacy obligations.
  8. Post Employment Cooperation: require reasonable help with handover, return of property and confirming compliance after exit.

If you also use contractors, don't assume a contractor agreement avoids employment law or removes the need for employee or contractor status advice. From 2026, Employment Relations Act changes include a contractor gateway test that may give more certainty where its requirements are met. If the arrangement doesn't meet the gateway, the usual worker status issues can still matter. Either way, restraints in contractor agreements still need to be reasonable and commercially justified.

It's also worth building protection into your everyday processes, not just the contract. Limit CRM exports, use personal logins, keep access role based, and run an exit checklist every time someone leaves. A good contract helps, but good records often make the contract useful.

Key Takeaways

  • You may be able to stop an ex employee taking clients, but only if your restraint or confidentiality obligations are clear and reasonable.
  • Non solicitation clauses are often more practical than broad non compete clauses for protecting client relationships.
  • Confidential information, such as client lists, pricing and proposal data, can give you stronger protection than a restraint alone.
  • Act quickly if you suspect client poaching: secure systems, preserve evidence, check the contract and keep communications factual.
  • Your employment agreements should be tailored to each role, especially where staff have client access, pricing knowledge or sales responsibility.
  • If the matter escalates into a dispute, get the right dispute specific support while also fixing your contracts and processes for the future.

If you'd like help with your employment contracts, restraint clauses, confidentiality protections or exit processes, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Get employment right

When should you get employment help?

Employment topics can become risky quickly when documentation, consultation, termination or contractor status is involved.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Get employment right

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.