Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.
Use an employment agreement when the person is really working in and for your business. Use a contractor agreement when they're genuinely running their own business and providing services to yours.
That sounds simple, but the line can get blurry fast. A designer helping with one campaign might be a contractor. A customer support person doing set shifts every week, using your systems and following your scripts, may look much more like an employee.
The good news is that you can work through this logically before you hire. A clear classification helps you choose the right agreement, budget properly, and avoid fixing expensive mistakes later.
Can I Hire Someone As A Contractor Instead Of An Employee?
Yes, you can hire someone as a contractor if the working relationship is genuinely a contracting arrangement. You can't just choose the label because it feels simpler or cheaper.
In New Zealand, the label in the agreement matters, but it isn't the whole story. The real question is how the relationship works in practice. If the person is under your control, works regular hours in your team, and is economically dependent on your business, calling them a contractor may not be enough.
For a startup, the distinction matters because employees and contractors sit under different legal frameworks.
- Employees are covered by the Employment Relations Act 2000 and minimum employment standards, including written employment agreements, holidays and leave under the Holidays Act 2003, PAYE, KiwiSaver obligations and other protections.
- Contractors usually provide services under a commercial contract. They manage their own tax, can often work for other clients, and don't get employee leave entitlements from your business.
Startups often lean towards contractors because it feels flexible. Flexibility can be legitimate, especially for project work. But if you need someone on set days, under close direction, doing ongoing work that's core to your business, an employment agreement may be the safer and cleaner option.
A useful starting point is this: if you need to manage the person like a team member, you may need to hire them like one.
What Is The Contractor Gateway Test In NZ?
The contractor gateway test is a 2026 change designed to give businesses more certainty when classifying some workers as contractors. It sits within the Employment Relations Act 2000, as amended by the Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026.
Broadly, if your arrangement meets all parts of the gateway test, the person is treated as a contractor for employment law status purposes. If you don't meet the test, that doesn't automatically mean they're an employee, but you'll need to look at the wider legal tests and the real nature of the relationship.
The gateway test looks at whether all of these requirements are met:
- you and the worker have a written agreement that specifies the worker is an independent contractor
- the worker isn't restricted from performing work for someone else, including a competitor, except while they're performing the relevant work for you
- you don't require the worker to be available to perform work at particular times of day, on particular days, or for a minimum number of hours, unless the worker can subcontract or delegate the work to another person
- where subcontracting or delegation is allowed, any vetting or limits you apply are only for permitted matters that are reasonably necessary for the work, such as skills, qualifications, health and safety, security, confidentiality, access, insurance or legal and regulatory requirements
- you don't end the contract just because the worker doesn't accept an additional task or engagement
- the worker had a reasonable opportunity to seek independent advice before entering into the arrangement
This test is helpful, but it isn't a box ticking shortcut. If your agreement says the person can work for others, but in reality you roster them 40 hours a week and require approval for any other work, your paperwork and practice won't line up.
Use the gateway test before you draft. If you can honestly satisfy each point, a tailored contractor agreement may fit. If you can't, pause before using a contractor template.
Employee Or Contractor Checklist For NZ Startups
It depends on the full working relationship, so use this checklist before you decide which agreement to send.
No single factor answers the question on its own. The more answers that point towards control, integration and ongoing personal work, the more likely you should be thinking about employment.
Step 1: Look At Control
- Will you decide when and where they work?
- Will you supervise their day to day tasks?
- Will they need permission to take time off or refuse work?
- Will they follow your internal policies, scripts or procedures in the same way as staff?
High control points towards employment. Contractors usually decide how to deliver the agreed outcome, within sensible commercial requirements.
Step 2: Look At Integration
- Will they appear on your team page or use your job title?
- Will they use your email address, tools and systems as their main work setup?
- Will customers think they're part of your business?
- Is the work ongoing and central to what your business sells?
The more integrated they are, the more they look like an employee.
Step 3: Look At Business Risk And Independence
- Do they invoice you through their own business or NZBN?
- Do they set their own rates?
- Do they provide their own equipment?
- Can they profit by working efficiently, or lose money if they quote badly?
- Can they work for other clients at the same time?
Real independence points towards contracting. If they're paid a fixed hourly wage with no real business risk, that points towards employment.
A Worked Example
Say Mia runs a Wellington SaaS startup. She needs a developer for 12 weeks to build a reporting dashboard. The developer charges $95 plus GST per hour, uses their own laptop, invoices fortnightly, works for two other clients, and can choose when to do the work as long as milestones are met. That looks like a contractor arrangement.
Now say Mia hires Sam for customer support from 9am to 1pm, Monday to Friday, at $28 per hour. Sam uses Mia's helpdesk, follows the support scripts, attends weekly team meetings and needs approval for time off. Even if Sam has an overseas business number or sends invoices, the practical setup looks much more like employment in New Zealand.
What Agreement Should I Use Once I Have Classified The Role?
Use an employment agreement for an employee, and a contractor agreement for a genuine contractor. The agreement should match the reality of how the work will be done.
If the person is an employee, New Zealand law requires a written employment agreement. Your agreement should cover the role, pay, hours, place of work, leave, notice, confidentiality, IP and any trial or probation arrangements that are lawful for your situation.
You also need to factor in employee costs and obligations, including:
- at least 4 weeks of annual holidays after 12 months of continuous employment under the Holidays Act 2003
- 10 days of sick leave per year after 6 months, if the employee meets the eligibility rules
- PAYE deductions and employer administration through Inland Revenue
- KiwiSaver employer contributions, generally at a minimum of 3.5% for eligible contributing employees, noting that rates are scheduled to change again so you should check the current Inland Revenue rate
- health and safety duties and record keeping obligations
If the person is a contractor, your agreement should focus on commercial delivery. You're buying an outcome or service, not managing an employee. The document should support that reality by dealing with scope, fees, invoicing, GST, IP ownership, confidentiality, subcontracting, liability and termination rights.
Templates can miss the details that matter most for startups, especially around IP, confidentiality and who owns work product. A lawyer should tailor the agreement before you use it, because a generic document that doesn't match the working arrangement can create more confusion.
What Should An Independent Contractor Agreement Include?
An independent contractor agreement should clearly describe the services, payment terms and the commercial relationship. It should also avoid employee style wording that undercuts your classification.
Here is a practical outline you can use when briefing your legal team.
- Parties: name your business correctly, including your company name and NZBN if relevant, and identify the contractor or their company.
- Contractor Status: state that the contractor is independent and isn't your employee, agent or partner.
- Services: describe the deliverables or services clearly, including any milestones, specifications or acceptance process.
- Timing: set project dates or deadlines without unnecessarily controlling the contractor's daily schedule.
- Fees And Invoicing: state the rate or fixed fee, whether GST is included or added, invoicing frequency and payment timing.
- Expenses: explain whether expenses need pre approval and what evidence is required for reimbursement.
- Tools And Equipment: record whether the contractor provides their own tools, software, insurance or licences.
- Subcontracting: say whether subcontracting is allowed, whether your written approval is needed, and when a sub-contractor agreement is required.
- Intellectual Property: make clear who owns the work product, when ownership transfers, and what pre existing materials are excluded.
- Confidentiality: protect your commercial information, customer data, code, pricing and product plans.
- Privacy And Data: require the contractor to handle personal information consistently with the Privacy Act 2020 where they access customer, staff or user data.
- Insurance And Liability: set any insurance expectations and responsibility for loss caused by the contractor's work.
- Ending The Contract: explain when either side can end the arrangement and what happens to unpaid invoices, materials and handover.
Be careful with clauses that look like employment controls. For example, requiring the contractor to work set weekly hours, get permission for leave and accept all tasks you assign may weaken the contractor position.
What Happens If I Get The Classification Wrong?
If you get the classification wrong, your business may need to back pay employment entitlements and fix tax, leave and record keeping issues. The practical cost is usually much higher than getting the agreement right at the start.
Misclassification can create several problems at once:
- Holiday And Leave Costs: someone treated as a contractor may later be found to have employee entitlements, including annual holidays and sick leave.
- Minimum Employment Standards: you may need to show you met minimum wage, wage record, time record and employment agreement obligations.
- Tax And KiwiSaver Issues: you may need to revisit PAYE, withholding tax settings and employer KiwiSaver contributions with Inland Revenue.
- IP Ownership Gaps: if your contractor agreement didn't properly assign IP, your business may not clearly own the code, designs, content or materials you paid for.
- Operational Disruption: reclassifying someone after they have started can affect budgets, team structure and investor due diligence.
If you're unsure, get employee or contractor advice before the person starts. Review the role, the level of control you need, the gateway test and the commercial terms. Then choose the agreement that matches the answer.
If someone is already working for you and the arrangement feels wrong, don't just rename the contract. Look at what is happening in practice, update the working model if needed, and get tailored help before making changes. A clean reset is much better than having inconsistent documents, invoices and instructions.
Key Takeaways
- You can use a contractor agreement only where the person is genuinely operating as an independent contractor.
- The 2026 contractor gateway test can help, but you need to meet all parts of it, including the independent advice opportunity, and your written contract and real working practices need to match.
- Control, integration, financial independence and the right to work for others are key classification factors.
- Employees need written employment agreements and minimum entitlements, including annual holidays, sick leave, PAYE administration and KiwiSaver obligations.
- Contractor agreements should cover scope, fees, GST, IP, confidentiality, privacy, subcontracting and termination.
- Getting the classification right before work starts protects your budget, your IP and your growth plans.
If you'd like help with classifying a role, preparing employment agreements, contractor agreements and IP terms, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.
Get employment right
When should you get employment help?
Employment topics can become risky quickly when documentation, consultation, termination or contractor status is involved.








