Black Friday10% off any legal service

Can You Make Staff Pay For Training If They Leave?

byAlex Solo10 min read

Can you make a staff member pay back training costs if they leave soon after you have invested in them? Sometimes, yes, but only if the arrangement is clear, fair and agreed upfront.

It's completely understandable to want some protection. Course fees, industry certificates and specialist onboarding can be expensive, especially when a new hire leaves before your business sees the benefit.

The trick isn't to treat every training cost the same. A well-drafted training repayment clause can be enforceable in New Zealand, but an overly broad clause can create penalty, wage deduction and employment law problems.

Can You Make Staff Pay For Training If They Leave?

Yes, you may be able to require an employee to repay training costs if they leave, but you'll usually need a clear written training agreement made before the training starts.

In practice, this is usually done through a training repayment clause in the employment agreement, or a separate training agreement signed before you pay for the course.

A good clause should explain:

  • what training you're paying for
  • the exact costs covered, or how they will be calculated
  • when repayment is triggered
  • how much the employee must repay
  • whether the amount reduces over time
  • whether you can deduct the amount from final pay, if the employee gives lawful written consent

Under the Employment Relations Act 2000, you and your employee must deal with each other in good faith. That matters here because a repayment clause shouldn't be sprung on someone after the course has already started, or hidden in wording they're unlikely to understand.

The clause also needs to sit comfortably with the Wages Protection Act 1983, the Holidays Act 2003 and the general law on penalties. If the clause goes too far, you may struggle to rely on it.

What Training Costs Can You Recover?

It depends on the type of training, but you're on safer ground recovering genuine external costs that give the employee a portable benefit.

For example, you may be able to recover some or all of:

  • external course fees paid to a training provider
  • exam fees or certification fees
  • professional accreditation costs
  • reasonable travel and accommodation costs for an external course, if agreed upfront
  • specialist training that gives the employee a qualification they can use elsewhere

You shouldn't require repayment of ordinary employment costs, such as:

  • recruitment costs
  • general onboarding
  • ordinary or required on-the-job training
  • time spent by your managers training a new starter
  • wages paid for work time or required training time
  • lost productivity while the employee was learning the role
  • training that your business must provide for health and safety or legal compliance

Employment New Zealand guidance is clear that required on-the-job training during normal work hours must be paid. Employers also need to be careful not to use a bond, deduction or repayment arrangement to claw back wages or ordinary on-the-job training costs. In some cases, those arrangements can be treated as unlawful premiums or fees for giving employment, or for keeping employment.

For example, if you run a food manufacturing business and staff need health and safety induction before they can safely work on site, that's a cost of running the business. Trying to make a departing employee repay that kind of compulsory training is likely to be risky and may be unlawful.

On the other hand, if you pay $3,000 for an employee to complete an external qualification that's recognised across your industry, it's more reasonable to ask for repayment if they resign soon afterwards, as long as the clause is properly drafted.

When Is A Training Repayment Clause Reasonable?

A training repayment clause is more likely to be reasonable when the amount reflects a genuine cost and reduces as your business receives the benefit of the training.

New Zealand courts can treat a clause as an unenforceable penalty if it's out of proportion to your legitimate business interest. In plain English, the clause should protect you from being left out of pocket, not punish the employee for leaving.

Factors that can help your clause look reasonable include:

  • the training is optional or above normal role training
  • the employee receives a recognised qualification or licence
  • the cost is significant for your business
  • the repayment period is limited, such as 6, 12 or 24 months depending on the cost and benefit
  • the amount reduces over time
  • repayment is triggered by resignation, not every possible exit
  • the clause doesn't apply if you terminate employment without fault, make the role redundant, or end employment in a way that isn't caused by the employee

Be careful with clauses that say the employee must repay 100% of the training cost even if they leave almost a year later. That can be hard to justify because your business has had some benefit from the training during that time.

It's also worth thinking about the tone of the clause. You want it to feel like a fair cost-sharing arrangement, not a trap. Clear wording helps avoid confusion and resentment later.

How Should A Sliding Scale Work?

A sliding scale usually works best when the repayment amount drops over time in line with the benefit your business receives from the training.

Here is a simple example.

Example: External Course Fee

Mike runs a cleaning business in Auckland. He pays $2,400 for Maia to complete a specialist floor restoration certification. The qualification is useful to Mike's business, but Maia can also use it with other employers.

Mike and Maia sign a training repayment agreement before the course starts. It says that if Maia resigns within 12 months of completing the course, she will repay:

  • 100% if she resigns within 3 months
  • 75% if she resigns after 3 months but within 6 months
  • 50% if she resigns after 6 months but within 9 months
  • 25% if she resigns after 9 months but within 12 months
  • 0% after 12 months

If Maia resigns 7 months after completing the course, the repayment amount is 50% of $2,400, which is $1,200.

That sliding scale is more defensible than demanding the full $2,400 at month 11. It recognises that Mike's business has had some use of Maia's new skills.

Your sliding scale should match the cost and the expected benefit period. A $600 short course may not justify a 24 month repayment period. A $12,000 specialist qualification might justify a longer period if the employee gets a valuable qualification and the terms are fair.

Can You Deduct Training Costs From Final Pay?

Only if you have a lawful basis to do so, and written consent is usually the key requirement.

The Wages Protection Act 1983 restricts when you can deduct money from an employee's wages. Even if your training repayment clause says the employee owes money, that doesn't automatically mean you can take it from their final pay.

To reduce the risk, your documents should clearly separate two issues:

  • repayment obligation: when the employee owes the training cost back to your business
  • deduction consent: whether you're allowed to deduct that amount from wages or final pay

The employee's written consent should be specific, informed and given before the deduction is made. A very broad clause saying you can deduct any amount from pay may not be enough, especially if the employee didn't understand what they were agreeing to.

If you're relying on a general deductions clause in the employment agreement, you must consult the employee before making a specific deduction. This means explaining what the deduction is for, when it will be made and how much will be deducted.

An employee can also vary or withdraw their written consent to deductions in writing. So, before deducting anything from final pay, check that the deduction authority still applies, hasn't been withdrawn and covers the amount you want to deduct.

You also need to be careful with final holiday pay and other minimum entitlements under the Holidays Act 2003. If the deduction would leave the employee short of legal entitlements, get tailored advice before making it.

A practical approach is to do this before the course starts and again if employment ends:

  1. Explain the training cost and repayment trigger in writing.
  2. Ask the employee to sign the training repayment clause or agreement.
  3. Include a separate written deduction authority if you want the option to deduct from final pay.
  4. If the employee resigns and the clause is triggered, confirm the amount, timing and reason for any proposed deduction.
  5. If relying on a general deductions clause, consult the employee before deducting and check their written consent is still effective.
  6. Keep records of the invoice, payment, signed agreement, consultation and repayment calculation.

If the employee doesn't consent to a deduction, or has withdrawn consent, you may still have a contractual claim for repayment, but you shouldn't simply take the money from wages and hope for the best.

Training Repayment Clause: What To Include

A good training repayment clause should be specific enough that everyone knows what is being paid for, when repayment applies and how the amount is worked out.

Templates can be a useful starting point, but careful clause drafting often turns on the details that make the clause workable for your business. A training repayment clause for a cafe barista course shouldn't look the same as one for a high-cost technical certification.

Here is a fill-in outline you can use when thinking through the clause. It isn't a finished legal document, and it should be tailored before you use it.

  1. Training Details: name the course, provider, qualification and expected completion date.
  2. Costs Covered: list the exact costs your business will pay, such as course fees, exam fees or travel.
  3. Employee Acknowledgement: record that the employee understands the repayment arrangement before training starts.
  4. Repayment Trigger: explain when repayment applies, such as resignation within a set period after completion.
  5. Exclusions: say when repayment won't apply, such as redundancy, performance management outcomes or termination without fault.
  6. Sliding Scale: set out the percentage payable at each stage of the repayment period.
  7. Deduction Authority: include separate written consent if you want the option to deduct from wages or final pay.
  8. Records And Evidence: state that your business will keep invoices and provide a calculation if repayment is triggered.
  9. Interaction With Employment Agreement: make sure the clause doesn't conflict with the employee's employment agreement.

If you engage contractors, don't use a contractor label just to avoid employment obligations. The Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026 introduced a contractor gateway test that can affect whether a worker is treated as an employee or contractor. If your business controls the worker closely and they look like part of your workforce, get employee or contractor advice before relying on a contractor training clause.

Common Mistakes To Avoid

The most common mistake is trying to recover too much, too late, without a clear written agreement.

Watch out for these issues:

  • Adding the clause after training starts: the employee should agree before your business pays or commits to the course.
  • Recovering ordinary employment costs: recruitment, induction, manager time and required on-the-job training should generally stay with the business.
  • Trying to claw back wages: required training time during normal work hours must be paid, and repayment arrangements for wages can create serious legal issues.
  • No sliding scale: a full repayment requirement throughout the whole period can look punitive.
  • Applying the clause to redundancy: asking for repayment when the exit isn't the employee's choice can be unfair and risky.
  • Deducting from final pay without consent or consultation: a repayment clause isn't always the same thing as deduction authority.
  • Using vague wording: phrases like 'all training costs' can create arguments about what is included.
  • Forgetting holiday pay: final pay calculations need to deal properly with Holidays Act 2003 entitlements.

If something has already gone wrong, slow down before making any deduction. Gather the signed agreement, course invoice, proof of payment, resignation date and your repayment calculation. Then check whether the clause actually allows repayment, whether you have written deduction consent and whether the employee has withdrawn or varied that consent.

If the wording is unclear, it's usually better to get advice before acting. A rushed deduction can turn a manageable repayment issue into a wider employment problem.

Key Takeaways

  • You can sometimes require staff to repay training costs if they leave, but the agreement should be clear, written and signed before training starts.
  • Repayment clauses work best for genuine external training costs, especially where the employee gains a portable qualification.
  • You shouldn't require repayment of wages, recruitment costs, ordinary onboarding or required on-the-job training.
  • A sliding scale helps show the clause is fair and not a penalty.
  • Before deducting from final pay, check written consent is still effective and consult the employee if you're relying on a general deductions clause.
  • Your clause should fit the cost, role, training benefit and reason employment ends.

If you'd like help with employment agreements, training repayment clauses, deduction wording or contractor arrangements, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Get employment right

When should you get employment help?

Employment topics can become risky quickly when documentation, consultation, termination or contractor status is involved.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Get employment right

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Keep reading

Related Articles

Can An Employer Deduct Training Costs From Final Pay?

Can An Employer Deduct Training Costs From Final Pay?

Need to recover training costs when an employee leaves? Here's when deductions from final pay can be lawful in New Zealand and how to set up safer clauses next time.

30 Oct 2026
Read more
Repayment Of Training Costs Clauses In NZ Employment Agreements

Repayment Of Training Costs Clauses In NZ Employment Agreements

Putting time and money into training your staff is one of the smartest investments you can make as a small business owner. But it can also feel risky - especially when you’ve...

12 Jun 2026
Read more
Training Bond Agreement Sample: What NZ Employers Need

Training Bond Agreement Sample: What NZ Employers Need

Paying for staff training is a great investment, but you need a fair agreement if you want repayment when someone leaves. Here's what NZ employers should include.

27 Oct 2026
Read more
Do Employers Have To Pay For Employee Training In New Zealand?

Do Employers Have To Pay For Employee Training In New Zealand?

If you’re running a small business, training is one of those “necessary but tricky” areas. You want your team to be capable, compliant and confident - but you also need to keep...

1 Apr 2026
Read more
Paid Training In New Zealand: Employer Obligations On Wages And Compliance

Paid Training In New Zealand: Employer Obligations On Wages And Compliance

Paid training can be a great way to set your team (and your business) up for success. Whether you’re onboarding a new hire, rolling out a new system, or upskilling staff for...

3 Jun 2026
Read more
Unpaid Training In New Zealand: Employer Compliance Requirements

Unpaid Training In New Zealand: Employer Compliance Requirements

Training is one of the best investments you can make in your team - it improves performance, reduces mistakes, and helps you deliver a better customer experience. But when you’re a small...

30 Jun 2026
Read more
Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.