Black Friday10% off any legal service

Online Shop Returns Policy Template NZ

byAlex Solo9 min read

Mia runs a small online clothing store from Wellington. A customer buys a $129 dress, wears it once, then emails to say the zip broke and asks for a refund. Another customer wants to return a sale item because they changed their mind about the colour.

If you're selling online, this is where a clear returns policy earns its keep. It helps your customers understand what they can expect, and it helps your team respond consistently when returns, refunds and exchanges come up.

The tricky part is that your policy can't just say whatever sounds convenient. In New Zealand, the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 and Fair Trading Act 1986 set some firm rules you need to build around.

Do I Need A Returns Policy For My Online Store?

No, there isn't a single law that says every online store must publish a returns policy, but you should have one if you sell goods online in New Zealand.

Your returns policy is where you explain how your business handles:

  • Faulty, damaged or misdescribed products
  • Refunds, replacements, repairs and exchanges
  • Change-of-mind returns, if you offer them
  • Return shipping costs, your shipping policy and instructions
  • Proof of purchase and condition requirements
  • Timeframes for contacting you and sending items back

Without a written policy, your team may end up making calls on the fly. That can lead to inconsistent outcomes, unhappy customers and messy Fair Trading Act issues if your website gives people the wrong impression.

A good policy doesn't need to be long or full of legal language. It should be practical, accurate and easy for customers to find before they buy. For most online stores, it's also worth connecting your returns policy with your online goods and services terms and conditions, so your checkout flow, product pages and customer service emails all say the same thing.

Templates can be a helpful starting point, but they often miss the details that matter for your product type, fulfilment model and customer promises. It's worth tailoring your returns wording before you publish it, especially if you sell higher-risk products, run promotions often or ship internationally.

What Does The Consumer Guarantees Act Say About Returns?

The Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 says your customers are entitled to remedies when your goods don't meet the required consumer guarantees.

For online shops, the main guarantees are that goods must:

  • Be of acceptable quality
  • Be fit for any particular purpose the customer told you about
  • Match the description, images or sample you provided
  • Be supplied with clear title, meaning the customer can own them properly
  • Have spare parts and repair facilities available for a reasonable time, where that applies

There's no fixed 7, 14 or 30 day CGA deadline for faulty goods. The question is usually whether the issue came up within a reasonable time, considering what the product is, how much it cost and how a reasonable customer would expect it to last.

If the problem is minor, you can usually choose whether to repair, replace or refund. You need to do this within a reasonable time. If you don't, the customer may be able to reject the goods and ask for a refund or replacement, or have the issue fixed elsewhere and recover reasonable costs from you.

If the problem is serious, the customer can usually choose between a refund or replacement, or keep the goods and claim compensation for the drop in value. A serious problem might be where the product is unsafe, doesn't do what it was bought for, is very different from your description or has a fault that would have stopped a reasonable customer from buying it.

Can I Say No Refunds Or Store Credit Only?

No, you can't use a no-refunds or store-credit-only rule to remove a customer's rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act.

You can choose not to offer refunds for change-of-mind purchases, but you still need to provide the right remedy if the goods are faulty, misdescribed or otherwise don't meet the legal guarantees.

Phrases like these can cause trouble if they're not carefully qualified:

  • No refunds
  • No refunds on sale items
  • Store credit only
  • Returns accepted within 14 days only
  • All purchases are final

The problem is that these statements can mislead customers into thinking they have fewer rights than the law gives them. That can raise issues under the Fair Trading Act 1986, which prohibits misleading and deceptive conduct and false or misleading representations.

A safer approach is to separate your legal obligations from your goodwill policy. For example, your policy might say that you don't offer refunds for change-of-mind purchases unless your policy says otherwise, but nothing in your policy limits the customer's rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act.

Sale items need the same care. If a shirt was discounted because the stitching defect was clearly disclosed before purchase, the customer usually can't return it because of that disclosed defect. But if the shirt has a different fault, or it doesn't match your description, their CGA rights still apply.

Can I Refuse Change-Of-Mind Returns?

Yes, you can refuse change-of-mind returns, unless you've promised to accept them.

New Zealand consumer law doesn't generally require you to refund a customer just because they picked the wrong size, found the item cheaper elsewhere or no longer want it. That said, many online stores offer a change-of-mind policy because it can build trust and reduce purchase hesitation.

If you do offer change-of-mind returns, set the rules clearly. You might cover:

  • How many days the customer has to contact you, such as 14 or 30 days if that's your chosen policy
  • Whether items must be unused, unworn, unopened or in original packaging
  • Whether the customer receives a refund, exchange or store credit
  • Who pays return shipping
  • Whether clearance, customised, hygiene-sensitive or digital products are excluded
  • What proof of purchase is needed

Once you publish a change-of-mind policy, you need to honour it. If your product page says free 30 day returns but your returns page says store credit only within 14 days, that inconsistency can create customer complaints, complaints handling issues and Fair Trading Act risk.

Let's go back to Mia's clothing store. Her policy says customers can return unworn full-price items within 21 days for store credit, but final-sale clearance items are excluded unless they're faulty. A customer buys a clearance skirt for $40 and later decides the colour doesn't suit them. Mia can refuse a change-of-mind return because the exclusion was clear. But if the skirt arrives with a broken zip that wasn't disclosed, Mia still needs to provide a CGA remedy.

What Should An Online Shop Returns Policy Template Include?

A returns policy template should explain your legal obligations and your store's own process. The sample wording below is a practical starting point you can adapt to your store, products and checkout flow.

Sample online shop returns policy wording:

Before publishing, tailor the wording so it matches how your business actually operates. If you offer free returns, extended holiday returns, exchanges for sizing, subscription products or international shipping, those details should be built into the wording.

For faulty goods, be careful with return shipping. As a practical rule, the customer shouldn't be left out of pocket for a problem your business is legally responsible for under your consumer guarantees policy. If the item is bulky, unsafe to ship or difficult to return, you may need to arrange collection or another practical solution.

For change-of-mind returns, you can usually require the customer to pay return postage if your policy says so clearly.

How Do Returns Fit With Ecommerce Terms And Conditions?

Your returns policy should work alongside your ecommerce terms and conditions, not sit off to the side saying something different.

Your website terms usually cover the whole buying process. They might include:

  • How orders are placed and accepted
  • Pricing, GST and payment terms
  • Delivery timeframes and shipping options
  • Risk and title in goods
  • Discount codes, promotions and gift cards
  • Customer accounts and acceptable website use
  • Returns, refunds and exchanges
  • Privacy and marketing communications

Your returns policy can then give the customer-facing detail. For example, your terms might say that returns are handled under your returns policy, and your returns page sets out the steps customers need to follow.

Worked Example: Faulty Headphones

Say you sell wireless headphones online for $89, plus $6 shipping. A customer contacts you after three weeks because the left earbud has stopped working. They send a short video showing the issue and their order number.

If the fault isn't caused by misuse, the headphones likely don't meet the guarantee of acceptable quality. Because the problem may be fixable and the product can be replaced, you might offer a replacement pair and pay the reasonable return postage. If you instead told the customer that all returns must be made within 14 days and only store credit is available, that wording could conflict with the CGA.

Your records should show what the customer reported, the evidence they provided, what remedy you offered, when you sent the replacement and any return shipping costs you covered. These records help if the issue is later questioned.

If you collect personal information during returns, such as photos, addresses, payment details or bank account information, your Privacy Act 2020 obligations may also be relevant. Only collect what you need, keep it secure and make sure your privacy policy matches what you actually do.

Common Mistakes To Avoid

The biggest mistake is writing a returns policy that sounds clear, but accidentally takes away rights customers have under New Zealand law.

Watch out for these common issues:

  • Using absolute no-refund wording: You can refuse change-of-mind refunds, but not valid CGA claims.
  • Applying one deadline to everything: A 14 day returns window may work for your goodwill policy, but it can't override the CGA for faulty goods.
  • Forgetting sale items: Discounted goods still come with consumer guarantees unless the particular defect was clearly disclosed.
  • Confusing store credit with refunds: Store credit may be fine for change-of-mind returns, but it may not be enough for a serious product failure.
  • Making customers pay for your legal remedy: For faulty goods, think carefully before requiring the customer to cover return shipping.
  • Letting pages contradict each other: Your product pages, checkout, FAQs, terms and returns policy should all line up.
  • Ignoring business customers: If you sell to other businesses, your customer contracts may be able to contract out of parts of the CGA, but only in writing, for business transactions, and only where it's fair and reasonable.

Also be careful with overseas customers. If you sell from New Zealand into other countries, local consumer laws in the customer's country may also apply. The right wording depends on where you sell, what you sell and how your checkout is set up.

A simple internal process can help your team apply the policy consistently:

  1. Ask for the order number and a clear description of the issue.
  2. Request photos, video or other evidence where reasonable.
  3. Check whether the issue is a fault, misdescription, delivery problem or change-of-mind request.
  4. Decide which remedy applies and record why.
  5. Confirm the next steps to the customer in writing.
  6. Keep records of the outcome, including refund amounts and shipping costs.

Key Takeaways

  • Your online store returns policy should explain both legal remedies and any goodwill change-of-mind options you choose to offer.
  • The Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 applies to faulty, unsafe, misdescribed or unsuitable goods, and you can't contract out of it for consumer sales.
  • No-refund, store-credit-only and strict deadline wording can be risky if it suggests customers have fewer rights than the law gives them.
  • You can usually set your own change-of-mind rules, but you need to state them clearly and honour what you promise.
  • Your template should include CGA savings wording, faulty goods, change-of-mind returns, shipping, proof of purchase, exclusions and privacy wording.
  • Your returns policy, ecommerce terms, product pages and checkout wording should all be consistent.

If you'd like help with online store returns wording, ecommerce terms, consumer law compliance and privacy documents, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Drafted by Taylor, Sprintlaw's AI, and overseen by Alex Solo. How we write

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Need legal help?

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.