Black Friday10% off any legal service

Subscription Terms Checklist For Online Memberships

byAlex Solo8 min read

Yes - if you're charging members on a weekly, monthly or annual basis, you should have written subscription terms that explain renewals, cancellations, failed payments and what members actually get.

The nuance is that recurring billing isn't just a contract issue. In New Zealand, the way you advertise, disclose and manage subscriptions can also raise Fair Trading Act 1986, Consumer Guarantees Act 1993, Privacy Act 2020 and payment processor issues.

The good news is that your terms don't need to be complicated. They just need to be clear, easy to find and matched to how your subscription actually works.

Do You Need Subscription Terms And Conditions In NZ?

Yes, you should have subscription terms and conditions in NZ if your business takes recurring payments, gives ongoing access to online services, content or other benefits, or runs a paid membership community.

Your terms are the rulebook for the relationship. They tell your members what they're paying for, when they'll be charged, how renewals work, how they can cancel and what happens if something goes wrong.

Without written terms, you may struggle to:

  • show that a member agreed to recurring payments
  • recover unpaid subscription fees
  • respond to a chargeback with clear evidence
  • apply cancellation cut-off dates consistently
  • explain limits on refunds or access
  • defend your billing process if a customer complains to their bank or the Commerce Commission

For example, say you run an online fitness membership for $39 a month. A customer joins during a promotion, uses the workouts for four months, then disputes every monthly payment with their bank because they say they didn't know it renewed. If your checkout only said Join Now and your terms were hidden at the bottom of your website, you may have a much harder time pushing back.

Good subscription terms help reduce that risk because they create a clear paper trail. They also help your customer experience, because members know what to expect before they enter their card details.

What Should Your Recurring Payment Terms Say?

Your recurring payment terms should clearly state the amount, billing frequency, renewal date, payment method and authority to charge the customer's nominated card or account.

This is where many subscription businesses get into trouble. The payment clause is technically there, but it's vague or buried in a long document. For recurring billing, clarity matters.

Your payment terms should cover:

  • Subscription price: the amount charged, including whether GST is included.
  • Billing cycle: weekly, monthly, quarterly, annually or another cycle.
  • First payment: whether the customer pays immediately, after a trial or on a set start date.
  • Automatic renewals: whether the subscription keeps renewing until cancelled.
  • Payment authority: permission to charge the nominated payment method for each renewal.
  • Price changes: how you'll notify members and when the new price applies.
  • Invoices and receipts: whether these are emailed or available in an account dashboard.

If you offer a free or discounted trial, be especially clear about what happens when it ends. For example: Your 7-day trial starts on 1 May. Unless you cancel before 11:59pm on 7 May, your first monthly payment of $49 will be charged on 8 May, then monthly after that.

That type of wording is easier for a member to understand and easier for you to rely on if there's a payment dispute.

How Should Your Cancellation Policy Work?

Your cancellation policy should explain exactly how a member cancels, when cancellation takes effect and whether any prepaid fees are refundable.

There isn't one set notice period that every New Zealand subscription business must use. What works depends on your billing model, how access is delivered and whether you incur costs upfront. The key is that your policy needs to be fair, clear and consistent with what you advertised.

A practical cancellation clause usually covers:

  • where the member goes to cancel, such as account settings or email support
  • what details they need to provide
  • whether cancellation is instant or takes effect at the end of the paid billing period
  • any cut-off time before the next renewal, such as 2 business days before the billing date
  • whether unused days, months or credits are refunded
  • what happens to member content, downloads, community access or stored data

Try to avoid a cancellation process that's much harder than signing up. If a member can join in two clicks but has to phone during limited hours to cancel, that can create complaints and Fair Trading Act risk, especially if the sign-up page didn't make this clear.

You should also avoid saying no refunds in a way that suggests statutory rights don't apply. Under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993, consumers may have remedies if services aren't provided with reasonable care and skill, aren't fit for a stated purpose or aren't delivered within a reasonable time. Your terms can set your commercial refund policy, but they shouldn't try to remove rights the law gives customers.

What Happens If A Payment Fails Or A Customer Charges Back?

Your terms should say what happens after a failed payment, but the process should be reasonable and easy to evidence.

Failed payments are normal in subscription businesses. Cards expire, banks decline transactions and customers forget which card they used. A clear failed payment process helps you recover revenue without surprising customers.

Your clause might say that if a payment fails, you'll notify the member, retry the payment and may suspend access if the amount remains unpaid.

A Worked Example

Imagine Maia runs a paid online photography membership at $29 per month. Her terms say payments are charged on the 15th of each month, failed payments may be retried after 3 days, and access may be paused if payment is still outstanding after 7 days.

On 15 June, a member's card fails. Maia's system emails the member the same day. It retries on 18 June and fails again. On 22 June, access is paused until the member updates their card. Because Maia's checkout, payment receipts and terms all match, she has a much clearer record if the member later disputes the June charge.

For chargebacks, your payment provider or bank will usually ask for evidence. Keep records of:

  • the sign-up date and time
  • the terms accepted at checkout
  • the subscription plan selected
  • renewal reminders or payment receipts sent
  • login or usage records, where appropriate
  • cancellation requests and your response

Payment processors also have their own rules, especially for trial conversions, recurring billing and customer disputes. Your online subscription terms should match the payment flow you actually use.

What Clauses Reduce Fair Trading Act Risk?

The clauses that reduce Fair Trading Act risk are the ones that make the commercial reality obvious before the customer pays.

The Fair Trading Act 1986 prohibits misleading and deceptive conduct, false representations and unfair contract terms in standard form consumer contracts and certain standard form trade contracts, including small trade contracts that meet the statutory threshold. For subscription businesses, the risk often isn't that the wording is missing altogether. It's that the key details are hidden, unclear or contradicted by your marketing.

Watch out for wording or checkout flows that make these points hard to spot:

  • a free trial becomes paid unless cancelled
  • the membership auto-renews
  • the price changes after an introductory period
  • cancellation must happen before a cut-off date
  • some features, downloads or services cost extra
  • refunds are limited after access has been granted

Your advertising, pricing page, checkout page, emails and terms should all say the same thing. If your ad says Cancel Anytime but your terms say cancellations need 30 days' notice and no partial refunds are given, that mismatch can cause trouble.

Unfair contract term rules also matter. A standard set of membership terms and conditions shouldn't give your business a very broad right to change prices, remove features, suspend accounts or terminate access without a fair process. You may need flexibility, but the clause should explain when you'll use it, what notice you'll give and what options the member has.

Privacy is another practical piece. If you collect names, emails, billing details, usage data or community profile information, your Privacy Act 2020 obligations should be covered in a separate privacy policy or clear privacy wording. If you send marketing emails, you should also think about consent and unsubscribe requirements under the Unsolicited Electronic Messages Act 2007.

Subscription Terms Checklist: What To Include

Your subscription terms should be tailored to your business model, but a good outline gives you a strong starting point.

Templates can miss the details that matter most in recurring billing, like trial conversion wording, retry timing, access suspension and how your cancellation button actually works. It's a good idea to have your terms tailored by a legal professional or legal team before you use them, especially if you sell to both consumers and businesses.

  1. Parties And Eligibility: state who the contract is between, who can join and any age, location or account requirements.
  2. Membership Benefits: describe what the subscription includes, such as content, courses, software, community access or support.
  3. Plans And Pricing: list how plans work, whether GST is included and where current prices are displayed.
  4. Recurring Payments: explain billing frequency, payment authority, renewal dates and receipts.
  5. Trials And Promotions: state when a free or discounted period ends and what the customer will be charged next.
  6. Cancellations: explain the cancellation method, cut-off time and when access ends.
  7. Refunds And Consumer Rights: set your refund rules without limiting rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993.
  8. Failed Payments: set out retries, notices, late payment handling and access suspension.
  9. Account Rules: cover passwords, sharing logins, acceptable use and community behaviour.
  10. Content And IP: explain who owns your materials and what members can and can't copy, share or reuse.
  11. Changes To The Service: explain when you can update features, prices or terms and what notice you'll give.
  12. Privacy And Communications: point to how you handle personal information and service emails.
  13. Liability Limits: set sensible limits that fit your service and don't try to exclude non-excludable consumer rights.
  14. Termination: explain when you can end or suspend a membership, such as misuse, non-payment or breach of rules.
  15. Governing Law: state that New Zealand law applies if that's the right position for your business.

Once the wording is ready, place it where it counts. Members should see and accept your terms at sign-up, not only after they've already paid.

Key Takeaways

  • Clear subscription terms help you prove what the customer agreed to, especially for automatic renewals and recurring payments.
  • Your cancellation policy should be easy to follow and should match the promises you make on your pricing and checkout pages.
  • Failed payment and chargeback clauses work best when they're backed up by good records, receipts and customer notices.
  • Fair Trading Act risk often comes from hidden trial conversions, unclear renewal terms or marketing that doesn't match the contract.
  • Your refund wording should sit alongside, not override, customer rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993.
  • A tailored document is safer than a generic template because recurring billing details vary a lot between businesses.

If you'd like help with your subscription terms, recurring payment clauses, cancellation policy and privacy settings, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Need legal help?

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.