Black Friday10% off any legal service

Can I Change My Terms After A Customer Has Paid?

byAlex Solo9 min read

Mia runs an online meal kit business in Wellington. A storm disrupts one of her suppliers, so she wants to move all deliveries from next-day delivery to delivery within 7 days. Some customers have already paid under terms that promised next-day delivery.

It feels like a practical operations issue, but legally it can become a contract variation, a Fair Trading Act issue and, for consumer customers, a Consumer Guarantees Act issue too.

The good news is that you usually have options. The safest path depends on what your current terms say, what you promised at checkout, and whether your customer actually agrees to the change.

Can You Change Terms After A Customer Has Paid?

Usually, no. Not for that existing order or service package unless the customer agrees, or your current contract clearly lets you make that kind of change.

Once a customer has accepted your offer and paid, you generally have a binding contract. The terms of sale that applied at the time of purchase are the starting point. If you later change your website terms, that usually affects future purchases only, not customers who have already paid.

For example, if your checkout page said delivery in 2 business days and your terms didn't give you a right to extend that timeframe, you shouldn't simply update your terms to say delivery in 10 business days for orders already placed.

That doesn't mean you're stuck with no choices. You may be able to:

  • ask the customer to agree to the new delivery or cancellation term
  • offer a refund, credit or alternative service
  • rely on a clear and fair variation clause in your existing terms
  • use a force majeure or delay clause, if it genuinely covers the situation
  • cancel the order if your existing terms allow it and consumer law doesn't prevent it

A contract variation is just a change to an existing contract. In practice, you want clear evidence that both sides agreed to the change. For online businesses, that may be a customer ticking a box, replying yes to an email, or accepting a new option in their account portal.

Silence is risky. If you email customers and say the new terms apply unless they object, that may not be enough unless your original terms clearly allowed that process.

What If Your Terms Say You Can Change Them?

It depends. A variation clause can help, but it isn't a blank cheque to rewrite the deal after payment.

Many online terms include wording that says the business may change its terms at any time. That wording is useful for future orders, but it may not let you change key terms for customers who have already paid. The more significant the change, the more careful you need to be.

A clause is more likely to be useful if it clearly explains:

  • which terms you can change
  • when changes can apply to existing customers
  • how much notice you'll give
  • what happens if the customer doesn't agree
  • whether the customer can cancel and receive a refund for the unused part

For example, a subscription service might say it can change delivery windows for future billing periods by giving 14 days' notice, and customers can cancel before the next renewal if they don't agree. That's much safer than saying you can change any term at any time without notice.

You also need to think about an unfair contract terms review under the Fair Trading Act 1986. New Zealand's unfair contract terms rules apply to standard form consumer contracts and small trade contracts. A small trade contract is generally one where each party is in trade, the contract isn't a consumer contract, and the trading relationship doesn't exceed $250,000, including GST if applicable, in any 12-month period when the relationship first arises.

A one-sided term that lets you change important parts of the deal, but gives the customer no real choice or remedy, may be at risk. The Commerce Commission can take action where businesses use unfair terms, and that can create cost, delay and reputational damage.

What Consumer Law Issues Should You Watch For?

You need to be especially careful with consumer customers because you can't use your terms to take away their rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993 or mislead them under the Fair Trading Act 1986.

The Consumer Guarantees Act gives customers automatic guarantees when they buy consumer goods or services. For services, the key guarantees include that services will be carried out with reasonable care and skill, be fit for purpose where the customer made that purpose known, and be completed within a reasonable time if no time was agreed.

For goods, the guarantees include acceptable quality, fitness for purpose, matching description, and other protections. If your delivery promise is part of the product or service you sold, changing it after payment can create a problem if the customer no longer gets what they paid for.

The Fair Trading Act also matters. You must not mislead customers about:

  • what they're buying
  • the delivery timeframe
  • their cancellation rights
  • whether refunds are available
  • whether your new terms override consumer law

A blanket no refunds statement can be misleading if it suggests customers don't have remedies under the Consumer Guarantees Act. You can have a change of mind policy, but it shouldn't be written in a way that removes legal rights for faulty goods, serious service failures or misleading claims.

For business customers, the Consumer Guarantees Act may not apply in the same way, and it can sometimes be contracted out of in writing where it's fair and reasonable. Still, the Fair Trading Act can apply to business dealings, so clear and accurate communication still matters.

How Does This Work For Online Stores And Subscriptions?

For online stores, the terms at checkout usually matter most for the order that has already been placed.

Your website terms, product page, checkout wording, order confirmation email and any service description can all form part of what the customer was promised. If they conflict, you may end up arguing about which wording applied. That's why it helps to keep your business terms and conditions consistent across the customer journey.

One-Off Online Orders

Say Mia sold 100 meal kits for $120 each. Her checkout page promised next-day delivery, and customers paid on Monday. On Tuesday, she changes her website terms to say delivery may take up to 7 days.

For the 100 customers who already paid, the new wording is unlikely to apply automatically. Mia should contact those customers and offer clear options, such as:

  • accept delivery within 7 days and receive a $15 credit
  • switch to a different available product for next-day delivery
  • cancel the order and receive a refund

If 70 customers choose the 7-day delivery option, Mia should keep a record of each acceptance. For the 30 who choose a refund or don't respond where timing is critical, cancelling and refunding may be the safer option than assuming they accepted the new term.

Subscriptions And Memberships

Subscriptions are different because you may have future billing periods. If your current terms allow changes for future periods, you can usually notify customers before the change takes effect.

For example, if customers pay monthly and your terms allow changes on 14 days' notice before the next billing date, you may be able to change the delivery window for the next month. You shouldn't backdate the change to services already paid for unless the customer agrees or your original terms clearly allowed it.

What Should You Do If You Need To Change Delivery, Cancellation Or Service Terms?

Start by pausing the rollout and checking what customers were actually promised before you announce the change.

Operational pressure can make it tempting to update your website first and sort out the details later. That can create more work if customers complain, ask for refunds or say you misled them. A clean process is usually faster in the long run.

Step 1: Find The Current Contract Terms

Check the version of your customer contract terms that applied when the customer paid. Also review the product page, checkout page, order confirmation and any sales emails. If you use a website platform, export or screenshot the relevant pages where you can.

Step 2: Identify The Type Of Customer

Work out whether you're dealing with consumer customers, business customers or both. Consumer customers usually have stronger statutory rights, and your terms can't remove those rights.

Step 3: Decide Whether The Change Is Minor Or Material

A small change, such as moving delivery from 10am to 2pm on the same day, may be easier to manage. A material change, such as removing cancellation rights, delaying delivery by 3 weeks or reducing what is included in a service package, usually needs express agreement or a refund option.

Step 4: Give Customers Real Options

Where the change affects existing paid orders, consider giving customers a choice. This might include accepting the change, moving to a substitute product or receiving a refund for the affected part.

Step 5: Keep A Clear Record

Keep records of the old terms, the reason for the change, your customer notice, each customer's response and any refunds or credits issued. Without a clear record, you may struggle to show what was agreed.

What Should Your Variation Notice Include?

A variation notice should be clear, specific and easy for the customer to respond to. It shouldn't hide the change in a long email or rely on vague wording.

Here is a practical outline you can adapt before getting it tailored to your business:

  1. Customer And Order Details: identify the customer, order number, subscription or service package affected.
  2. Current Term: state the term that currently applies, such as the delivery timeframe or cancellation window.
  3. Proposed New Term: explain the exact replacement wording in plain English.
  4. Reason For The Change: give a short and accurate explanation, without overpromising or blaming others unnecessarily.
  5. Customer Options: set out whether the customer can accept, cancel, receive a refund, receive a credit or choose an alternative.
  6. Response Deadline: give a reasonable date for the customer to respond, especially if the service is time-sensitive.
  7. Refunds Or Credits: explain how any refund or credit will be calculated and when it will be processed.
  8. Effective Date: state when the new term will start if the customer agrees.
  9. Contact Details: tell the customer how to ask questions or choose an option.
  10. Record Of Agreement: ask the customer to confirm their choice in a way you can store, such as an email reply or account selection.

This outline isn't a finished legal document. Your wording should be tailored before you use it, especially if you have customer contracts with many customers, subscription billing, high-value orders or a mix of consumer and business customers.

Try to avoid wording that pressures customers to accept. If the customer has already paid for something specific, a fair option is often to let them walk away from the affected part without penalty.

Key Takeaways

  • Changing your website terms usually affects future purchases, not customers who have already paid.
  • You generally need customer agreement to change delivery, cancellation or service terms for an existing paid order.
  • A variation clause can help, but it needs to be clear, fair and consistent with the Fair Trading Act 1986.
  • Consumer customers keep their rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993, even if your terms say something different.
  • For online stores and subscriptions, keep records of the terms at checkout and each customer's response to any proposed change.
  • A clear variation notice with real options can protect your business and keep customer trust intact.

If you'd like help with your customer terms, online store terms, subscription wording or customer variation notices, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Need legal help?

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.