Black Friday10% off any legal service

Can A Contractor Work For Your Competitor Too?

byAlex Solo11 min read

Using contractors can be a smart way to get specialist help without hiring a permanent team member. But it can feel uncomfortable when that contractor also wants to work for a competitor, especially if they know your pricing, customers, systems or growth plans.

So, can you stop them? Sometimes, yes. But in New Zealand, the way you do it matters. A heavy-handed exclusivity or non-compete clause can be hard to enforce, and it can also create employment status issues you may not have intended.

The aim is to protect what genuinely matters to your business without treating the contractor so much like an employee that the relationship becomes legally messy.

Can A Contractor Work For Your Competitor In New Zealand?

Yes, unless their contractor agreement validly restricts it or there's another legal reason they can't, such as misuse of your confidential information or a conflict of interest.

Independent contractors are usually free to run their own business, choose their clients and work for more than one customer. That's one of the key differences between a contractor and an employee.

If you want a contractor to avoid competitor work, you normally need clear wording in your contractor agreement. A casual verbal understanding like "we assumed you wouldn't work with competitors" is rarely enough.

That said, you don't always need a full ban. Depending on the role, you might be better protected by clauses that deal with:

  • Confidentiality: stopping the contractor from using or sharing your business information.
  • Conflict of interest: requiring disclosure and approval before they work with certain businesses.
  • Non-solicitation: stopping them from poaching your customers, staff or suppliers.
  • IP ownership: making sure work created for you belongs to your business.
  • Targeted competitor controls: limiting specific high-risk work, while understanding this may affect contractor status settings.

For example, if you hire a freelance marketing strategist to build your product launch plan, you may not need to stop them working with every business in your industry. But you may have a strong reason to stop them working on a direct competitor's launch at the same time, using similar strategy, customer research or advertising angles.

Can You Put A Non-Compete In A Contractor Agreement?

Yes, you can include a non-compete clause in a contractor agreement, but it needs to be reasonable and carefully drafted if you want it to hold up.

New Zealand courts tend to look closely at restraint clauses. A clause that stops someone from earning a living or running their own business for no good reason is unlikely to be treated favourably.

To have a better chance of being enforceable, a contractor restraint should protect a legitimate business interest, such as:

  • trade secrets or sensitive commercial information
  • customer relationships the contractor was introduced to through your business
  • your pricing, supplier arrangements or sales pipeline
  • confidential product, software, marketing or operational plans
  • goodwill in your brand or customer base

It should also be no wider than needed. Think about the work the contractor is actually doing. A bookkeeper with access to your margins and customer data may justify tighter limits than a photographer taking one set of website images.

Reasonableness usually turns on factors like:

  • Time: Is the restraint for the project period only, 3 months, 6 months or longer?
  • Scope: Does it only cover direct competitors, or does it cover the whole industry?
  • Geography: Is it limited to New Zealand, a region, or no location at all?
  • Role: Does it only restrict similar work, or all work for another business?

A broad clause saying the contractor can't work for "any competing business anywhere" for 2 years is likely to be difficult to justify for many small businesses. A narrower clause that applies during the engagement, and only to named direct competitors or a clearly defined competing service, is usually more practical for restraint enforceability. However, even a narrow restriction can still affect whether you can rely on the specified contractor gateway if it restricts the contractor from working for others outside the time they're actually performing your work.

Will An Exclusivity Clause Make A Contractor Look Like An Employee?

It can increase the risk, especially if the exclusivity clause sits alongside other controls that make the contractor look like part of your workforce.

Under the Employment Relations Act 2000, the real nature of the relationship matters. A written label saying "independent contractor" helps, but it isn't the whole answer if the practical relationship looks like employment.

The Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026 introduced a specified contractor gateway test into New Zealand employment settings. In broad terms, the gateway is designed to give more certainty where a written agreement and the practical working arrangement show a genuine contracting relationship.

One important gateway requirement is that the specified contractor must not be restricted from performing work or services for any other person, except while they're performing work or services for you. This includes work for competitors. So, it isn't just very broad restraints that create a gateway problem. Even a narrow competitor restriction, exclusivity clause or non-compete may mean you can't rely on the gateway if it stops the contractor from working for someone else outside the time they're actually performing your work.

That doesn't automatically make the person an employee. It means the relationship may need to be considered under the wider "real nature" assessment instead. Narrow drafting can still help with restraint enforceability and with showing the relationship is commercially sensible overall, but it shouldn't be treated as a way to preserve the gateway if the restriction goes beyond the permitted exception.

Other factors that can increase employment status risk include:

  • requiring the contractor to work fixed hours like your employees
  • stopping them from sending a suitably qualified substitute
  • requiring them to accept ongoing work or extra tasks
  • integrating them into your team in the same way as staff
  • paying them like wages rather than against invoices
  • giving them your tools, systems and day-to-day supervision in a way that looks like employment

This is where balance matters. If the contractor genuinely needs to be exclusive, say why and keep the restriction targeted. If you only need to protect confidential information, a confidentiality and conflict clause may do the job with less status risk.

What's The Difference Between Exclusivity, A Non-Compete And A Conflict Of Interest?

They overlap, but they're not the same. Choosing the right clause helps you protect the business without going further than you need.

Exclusivity

An exclusivity clause says the contractor can't work for others, or can't work for certain types of clients, while they work with you.

This is the strongest option and can be useful for high-trust, high-access roles. But it can also be the riskiest for contractor status because it limits the contractor's ability to run an independent business. If it restricts work for others beyond the time the contractor is actually performing your work, it may also prevent you relying on the specified contractor gateway.

Non-Compete

A non-compete stops the contractor from working with competitors, either during the engagement or for a period after it ends.

For contractors, a post-engagement non-compete should be used carefully. Often, a non-solicitation clause and confidentiality clause will be easier to justify than a broad ban on competitor work after the project ends.

Conflict Of Interest

A conflict of interest clause doesn't always ban competitor work. Instead, it requires the contractor to tell you about competing engagements or other interests that could affect their duties to your business.

This can be a good middle ground. You might say the contractor must disclose any work for a direct competitor, and you can refuse approval where there's a real risk to confidential information, delivery quality or your customer relationships.

For many small businesses, a conflict clause plus strong confidentiality wording is more flexible than a full exclusivity clause. It gives you visibility without automatically stopping the contractor from earning income elsewhere.

What Should You Put In A Contractor Agreement To Protect Your Business?

You should include clauses that match the actual risk, not a blanket restriction copied from a template. Templates often miss the practical details that decide whether a restraint is reasonable.

Here is a fill-in outline you can use to plan the key sections before getting the agreement tailored. It isn't a finished legal document, and the wording should be adapted to your business, the contractor's role and the level of access they'll have.

  1. Parties And NZBN Details: list your legal business name, NZBN if you have one, and the contractor's legal name or company details.
  2. Services: describe the exact services, deliverables and any standards or milestones.
  3. Independent Contractor Status: state that the contractor is independent, controls how the services are performed, and clarify employee or contractor status and is responsible for their own tax and business costs.
  4. Fees And Invoicing: set out rates, GST treatment if relevant, invoice timing and payment dates.
  5. Availability And Subcontracting: explain any availability expectations and whether the contractor can use approved substitutes or subcontractors, and when a subcontractor agreement is needed.
  6. Confidential Information: define what is confidential and ban use or disclosure except for performing the services.
  7. Conflict Of Interest: require the contractor to disclose work that may conflict with your business, especially direct competitor work, and follow any conflict of interest policy.
  8. Exclusivity Or Non-Compete: include a narrow restriction only if you have a real business reason, define the time, scope and competitors clearly, and check the impact on contractor status and the specified contractor gateway.
  9. Non-Solicitation: stop the contractor from approaching your customers, staff or suppliers for a limited period if that risk exists.
  10. Intellectual Property: say who owns work product, when ownership transfers and what pre-existing materials the contractor keeps.
  11. Privacy And Data Security: require compliance with the Privacy Act 2020 where personal information is handled.
  12. End Of Engagement: cover notice, return of materials, deletion of data and final invoices.

If the contractor will access customer personal information, make sure your privacy settings are clear too. Under the Privacy Act 2020, your business needs to manage personal information properly, including collection, use, storage and disclosure. If the contractor is handling that data for you, their obligations should be written down.

How Do You Decide If A Competitor Restriction Is Worth It?

You should start with the practical risk, then choose the narrowest restriction that protects it. This keeps the clause more realistic and helps reduce contractor status issues.

Say Mia runs a Wellington-based SaaS business. She hires Arun, an independent UX contractor, for a 10-week redesign of her onboarding flow. Arun will see customer research, conversion data, product roadmaps and pricing ideas.

Mia is worried because Arun also works with another SaaS company. A full 12-month ban on working for any SaaS business in New Zealand would be too wide for what she needs. A more balanced approach for restraint purposes could look like this:

  • Arun must not work on onboarding redesigns for 3 named direct competitors during the 10-week project.
  • Arun must disclose any new SaaS clients during the project if the work overlaps with onboarding, pricing or conversion strategy.
  • Arun can't use Mia's customer research, analytics, roadmap or internal documents for anyone else.
  • Arun can't approach Mia's customers for his own business for 6 months after the project.
  • Arun can keep working for other non-competing SaaS clients, as long as there's no conflict.

That approach targets the real concern without stopping Arun from running his business more than necessary. It may also sit more comfortably with the wider real nature assessment than a broad industry ban. But Mia should understand that the first restriction may still prevent reliance on the specified contractor gateway if it stops Arun working for others outside the time he is actually performing Mia's work.

Before you draft a restriction, ask yourself:

  • What exactly are we trying to protect?
  • Could confidentiality, IP and non-solicitation clauses solve the problem?
  • Which competitors genuinely create a conflict?
  • How long does the risk actually last?
  • Will this restriction make the contractor look too much like an employee?
  • Could this restriction stop us relying on the specified contractor gateway?

If you can't explain the reason clearly, the clause may be too broad.

What If Your Contractor Is Already Working For A Competitor?

First, check the contractor agreement and gather the facts before you react. You want to understand whether there's a real breach, a confidentiality issue or simply an uncomfortable but permitted overlap.

Work through this in order:

  1. Read The Agreement: check the confidentiality, conflict, exclusivity, non-compete, non-solicitation, IP and termination clauses.
  2. Confirm The Facts: identify who the competitor is, what work the contractor is doing and when it started.
  3. Check Access: list the information, systems, customer lists and strategy documents the contractor can access.
  4. Record Your Concerns: keep notes of dates, communications and any evidence of information being shared or misused.
  5. Limit Access If Needed: where there's a genuine risk, consider pausing access to sensitive systems while you get advice.
  6. Talk To The Contractor: ask for disclosure and clarification in a calm, factual way.
  7. Get Tailored Advice: especially before ending the contract, alleging breach or relying on a restraint.

Avoid jumping straight to threats. If the agreement allows competitor work, your strongest protection may be enforcing confidentiality, IP ownership, privacy and data access controls rather than trying to stop the contractor's other engagement.

If there may be an employee or contractor status issue, be careful with your next steps. Ending the arrangement in a way that looks like disciplining an employee can add complexity. Get advice before making major changes to hours, access, payment or termination.

Key Takeaways

  • A contractor can usually work for your competitor unless a clear and valid agreement restricts it.
  • Non-compete and exclusivity clauses need to be reasonable, targeted and linked to a real business interest.
  • Under the 2026 specified contractor gateway, even a narrow competitor restriction may prevent reliance on the gateway if it restricts work for others beyond the time the contractor is actually performing your work.
  • Narrow drafting can still help with restraint enforceability and the wider real nature assessment, but it doesn't automatically preserve the gateway.
  • Confidentiality, conflict of interest, IP ownership and non-solicitation clauses often protect your business with less risk than a full ban.
  • If a contractor is already working for a competitor, check the agreement, confirm the facts and get advice before taking strong action.

If you'd like help with your contractor agreements, exclusivity and conflict clauses, confidentiality protections or contractor status settings, you can reach us at 0800 002 184 or team@sprintlaw.co.nz for a free, no-obligations chat.

Lock in the contract

Turning the information into a usable contract

Once money, deliverables or customer obligations are involved, the next step is usually a clear contract that matches how the business actually works.

Alex Solo
Alex SoloCo-Founder

Alex is a co-founder of Sprintlaw. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.

Lock in the contract

Get in touch with our team

Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a fixed-fee quote - no obligation, no surprises.

Keep reading

Related Articles

Need support?

Need help with your business legals?

Speak with Sprintlaw to get practical legal support and fixed-fee options tailored to your business.